Prescrire Int. 2008 Dec;17(98):230-2.
(1) Bortezomib prolongs survival in patients with relapsed or refractory multiple myeloma by a few months, but it provokes frequent and sometimes severe adverse effects. Thalidomide is generally used as a last resort; (2) Lenalidomide, a structural analogue of thalidomide, is licensed for the treatment of multiple myeloma, in combination with dexamethasone, after failure of the initial treatment regimen; (3) There are no comparative trials versus bortezomib or thalidomide; (4) Combined analysis of 2 randomised double-blind trials of lenalidomide + dexamethasone versus placebo + dexamethasone in a total of 704 patients showed that adding lenalidomide to dexamethasone slightly increased the one-year survival rate, from 75% to 82%. When this combination was used, the median time to tumour progression was 11 months. In clinical trials, the median time to tumour progression was about 2 years with thalidomide and 8 months with bortezomib; (5) In clinical trials, lenalidomide, like thalidomide, provoked deep venous thrombosis (9% versus 4% with placebo) and pulmonary embolism (4% versus 1%). Lenalidomide, unlike thalidomide, does not appear to cause peripheral neuropathy, but it does provoke cardiac arrhythmia such as atrial fibrillation (18% versus 11% with placebo) and severe haematological disorders, including neutropenia (35% versus 3% with placebo), thrombocytopenia (13% versus 6%) and anaemia (11% versus 6%); (6) The teratogenic effect of lenalidomide has not been adequately documented; (7) Lenalidomide costs about 40% more than bortezomib in France; (8) In patients with relapsed or refractory multiple myeloma there is no evidence that lenalidomide has a more favourable risk-benefit balance than bortezomib or even thalidomide.
(1) 硼替佐米可使复发或难治性多发性骨髓瘤患者的生存期延长数月,但会引发频繁且有时严重的不良反应。沙利度胺一般作为最后手段使用;(2) 来那度胺是沙利度胺的结构类似物,在初始治疗方案失败后,与地塞米松联合使用已获许可用于治疗多发性骨髓瘤;(3) 尚无与硼替佐米或沙利度胺的对比试验;(4) 对两项来那度胺+地塞米松与安慰剂+地塞米松的随机双盲试验进行的联合分析,涉及总共704例患者,结果显示在 地塞米松中添加来那度胺可使一年生存率略有提高,从75%升至82%。使用这种联合疗法时,肿瘤进展的中位时间为11个月。在临床试验中,使用沙利度胺时肿瘤进展的中位时间约为2年,使用硼替佐米时为8个月;(5) 在临床试验中,来那度胺与沙利度胺一样,会引发深静脉血栓形成(9%,而安慰剂组为4%)和肺栓塞(4%,而安慰剂组为1%)。与沙利度胺不同,来那度胺似乎不会导致周围神经病变,但会引发心律失常,如心房颤动(18%,而安慰剂组为11%)以及严重血液系统疾病,包括中性粒细胞减少(35%,而安慰剂组为3%)、血小板减少(13%,而安慰剂组为6%)和贫血(11%,而安慰剂组为6%);(6) 来那度胺的致畸作用尚未得到充分记录;(7) 在法国,来那度胺的成本比硼替佐米高约40%;(8) 在复发或难治性多发性骨髓瘤患者中,没有证据表明来那度胺的风险效益比优于硼替佐米,甚至也不比沙利度胺更优。