Mine Madisa, Bedi Keabetswe, Maruta Talkmore, Madziva Dignity, Tau Modiri, Zana Tatenda, Gaolathe Tendani, Moyo Sikhulile, Seipone Khumo, Ndwapi Ndwapi, Essex Max, Marlink Richard
National Health Laboratory, 5353 Church Road, Extension 10, Gaborone, Botswana.
J Virol Methods. 2009 Jul;159(1):93-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jviromet.2009.03.008. Epub 2009 Mar 20.
Roche COBAS Amplicor monitor version 1.5 assay is considered gold standard for viral load monitoring in Botswana. Due to its demand for elaborate infrastructure, viral load testing has been confined to the national HIV reference laboratories. Cavidi ExaVir Load version 2 assay was considered as a potential alternative to decentralize viral load testing to the rural/remote hospital laboratories and thus increase access to therapy. This study compared the performance of ExaVir Load v2 assay at a district hospital laboratory in Serowe and COBAS Amplicor monitor v1.5 assay at the Botswana Harvard HIV Reference Laboratory using quality assessment samples and plasma from HIV-positive individuals. ExaVir Load v2 and COBAS Amplicor monitor v1.5 assays had very good agreement; Kappa statistic 0.951. The COBAS Amplicor monitor v1.5 and ExaVir Load v2 assays detected HIV-1 RNA in 84 and 86 samples but did not detect HIV-1 RNA in 221 and 219 samples, respectively. The two assays detected HIV-1 RNA concordantly in 82 samples and were strongly correlated (r=0.8554, P<0.0001). ExaVir Load v2 assay provided a simple and reliable alternative viral load system that is adaptable to district hospital laboratories. The cost per test is less than RT-PCR. The ExaVir Load v2 systems have since been placed in four more district and primary hospital laboratories.
罗氏COBAS Amplicor监测仪1.5版本检测法被视为博茨瓦纳病毒载量监测的金标准。由于其对精密基础设施的需求,病毒载量检测一直局限于国家艾滋病病毒参考实验室。Cavidi ExaVir Load 2版本检测法被认为是将病毒载量检测分散到农村/偏远医院实验室从而增加治疗可及性的一种潜在替代方法。本研究使用质量评估样本和来自艾滋病毒阳性个体的血浆,比较了塞罗韦一家地区医院实验室的ExaVir Load v2检测法与博茨瓦纳哈佛艾滋病病毒参考实验室的COBAS Amplicor监测仪v1.5检测法的性能。ExaVir Load v2检测法和COBAS Amplicor监测仪v1.5检测法具有很好的一致性;卡帕统计值为0.951。COBAS Amplicor监测仪v1.5检测法和ExaVir Load v2检测法分别在84个和86个样本中检测到了艾滋病毒1型RNA,但在221个和219个样本中未检测到艾滋病毒1型RNA。这两种检测法在82个样本中一致检测到了艾滋病毒1型RNA,且相关性很强(r = 0.8554,P < 0.0001)。ExaVir Load v2检测法提供了一种简单可靠的替代病毒载量系统,适用于地区医院实验室。每次检测的成本低于逆转录聚合酶链反应。此后,ExaVir Load v2系统已被安置在另外四家地区和基层医院实验室。