Himmrich Ewald, Kettering Klaus, Münzel Thomas
II. Medizinische Klinik und Poliklinik, Universitätsmedizin der Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz, Langenbeckstrasse 1, 55131 Mainz.
Herz. 2009 May;34(3):176-85. doi: 10.1007/s00059-009-3218-5.
This review gives an integrated summary of the three old and two new ECG algorithms for the differential diagnosis of monomorphic regular tachycardias with broad QRS complex. Several studies have provided evidence that a ventricular tachycardia was diagnosed correctly by doctors on call and emergency physicians only in 35-50% of cases. Whether an algorithm may really improve diagnosis in everyday clinical practice and whether the algorithms are feasible for physicians, has not yet been clarified.The algorithms possess a high sensitivity of 88-95%, but only a satisfactory specificity of 73-80%. The values of all algorithms are similar. In the hands of physicians with little experience, the incidence of correct diagnoses is likely to be markedly lower. The algorithms have considerable limitations, especially with regard to the application of the "morphology criteria". As the nondetection of a ventricular tachycardia can have fatal consequences for the patient, any tachycardia with broad QRS complex should be treated as ventricular tachycardia in emergencies. In hemodynamically stable patients, the administration of adenosine for diagnostic purposes should immediately lead to a correct diagnosis. Based on the study situation, a schematic representation for the differential diagnosis has been created which follows very simple ECG criteria identifiable by any physician.
本综述对三种旧的和两种新的心电图算法进行了综合总结,这些算法用于鉴别诊断伴有宽QRS波群的单形性规则心动过速。多项研究表明,值班医生和急诊医生仅在35%-50%的病例中正确诊断出室性心动过速。一种算法是否真的能在日常临床实践中改善诊断,以及这些算法对医生来说是否可行,目前尚未明确。这些算法具有88%-95%的高灵敏度,但特异性仅为73%-80%,令人满意。所有算法的值相似。在经验不足的医生手中,正确诊断的发生率可能会明显更低。这些算法有相当大的局限性,尤其是在“形态学标准”的应用方面。由于未检测到室性心动过速可能对患者造成致命后果,因此在紧急情况下,任何伴有宽QRS波群的心动过速都应视为室性心动过速进行治疗。在血流动力学稳定的患者中,为诊断目的使用腺苷应能立即得出正确诊断。基于研究情况,已创建了一种遵循任何医生都能识别的非常简单的心电图标准的鉴别诊断示意图。