Grimm W, Menz V, Hoffmann J, Maisch B
Zentrum für Innere Medizin-Abt. Kardiologie, Philipps-Universität Marburg.
Z Kardiol. 1996 Dec;85(12):932-42.
In 240 tachycardias with wide QRS-complex (> or = 120 ms), the value of the "old" ECG criteria published in 1978 by Wellens and coworkers was compared to the "new" ECG criteria published in 1991 by Brugada and coworkers for the differential diagnosis of tachycardias with wide QRS-complex. As main result of the study, it could be demonstrated that with the old as well as with the new ECG criteria a sensitivity of more than 90% for the correct diagnosis ventricular tachycardia can be reached. The specificity of the old and new ECG criteria for the diagnosis ventricular tachycardia is 70% and 72% for tachycardias with right bundle branch block configuration and 87% each for tachycardias with left bundle branch block configuration. The combined use of the old and the new ECG criteria in this study could not increase sensitivity and specificity for the diagnosis of ventricular tachycardia. Therefore, it does not appear to be important for the differential diagnosis of tachycardias with wide QRS-complex whether the old or the new step diagnostic criteria are being used, but that either the old or the new ECG criteria are being used correctly.
在240例QRS波增宽(≥120毫秒)的心动过速患者中,将1978年Wellens及其同事发表的“旧”心电图标准与1991年Brugada及其同事发表的“新”心电图标准用于宽QRS波心动过速的鉴别诊断进行比较。作为该研究的主要结果,可以证明,无论是采用旧的还是新的心电图标准,对室性心动过速的正确诊断敏感性均可达到90%以上。对于右束支传导阻滞形态的心动过速,旧的和新的心电图标准诊断室性心动过速的特异性分别为70%和72%;对于左束支传导阻滞形态的心动过速,特异性均为87%。在本研究中,联合使用旧的和新的心电图标准并不能提高室性心动过速诊断的敏感性和特异性。因此,对于宽QRS波心动过速的鉴别诊断而言,使用旧的还是新的分步诊断标准似乎并不重要,重要的是要正确使用旧的或新的心电图标准。