Jawaid Masood, Masood Zubia, Ayubi Tarique Kamal
Department of Surgery, Dow University of Health Sciences and Civil Hospital, Karachi.
J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2009 Jun;19(6):350-3.
To evaluate the adequacy of pre-operative analgesia and patient's satisfaction at the accident and emergency department, in terms of pain relief.
Observational study.
The Accident and Emergency Department (A&E) of Civil Hospital, Karachi, during April and May, 2007.
Patients presenting with acute abdomen or tauma were included. Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) was used to grade severity of pain. Pain at presentation, analgesic prescribed, post-analgesic residual pain and patient satisfaction were assessed.
A total of 166 patients (109 males and 57 females) were enrolled in the study. It included 98 (59%) cases of trauma and 68 (41%) patients with acute abdomen. Mean pain score was 6.95+/-2.03 on VAS. Female patients (p=0.008) and patients with acute abdomen (p<0.001) experienced significantly more pain as compared to male and trauma patients respectively. Analgesics were prescribed to 104 (62.7%) patients. Post-analgesic mean residual pain score was 5.0+/-1.8. Out of them, 47.1% patients waited to be given more analgesia. There was significant less prescription of analgesic to patients with acute abdomen (52.9%) as compared to trauma patients (26.5%) (p=0.001). Overall, more than half of the patients (59.6%) were not satisfied with the pre-operative analgesic treatment in the A&E department.
Pre-operative analgesia was underprescribed and pain was undertreated in accident and emergency department resulting in more than half patients being not satisfied.
从疼痛缓解方面评估急诊部门术前镇痛的充分性及患者满意度。
观察性研究。
2007年4月至5月期间,卡拉奇市民医院急诊科。
纳入出现急腹症或创伤的患者。采用视觉模拟评分法(VAS)对疼痛严重程度进行分级。评估就诊时的疼痛、开具的镇痛药、镇痛后的残余疼痛及患者满意度。
本研究共纳入166例患者(109例男性和57例女性)。其中包括98例(59%)创伤病例和68例(41%)急腹症患者。VAS平均疼痛评分为6.95±2.03。女性患者(p = 0.008)和急腹症患者(p < 0.001)分别比男性和创伤患者经历了明显更多的疼痛。104例(62.7%)患者开具了镇痛药。镇痛后平均残余疼痛评分为5.0±1.8。其中,47.1%的患者等待给予更多镇痛药。与创伤患者(26.5%)相比,急腹症患者(52.9%)的镇痛药处方明显更少(p = 0.001)。总体而言,超过一半的患者(59.6%)对急诊科的术前镇痛治疗不满意。
急诊部门术前镇痛处方不足,疼痛治疗不充分,导致超过一半的患者不满意。