Cukiert Arthur, Cukiert Cristine Mella, Argentoni Meire, Baise-Zung Carla, Forster Cássio Roberto, Mello Valeria Antakli, Burattini José Augusto, Mariani Pedro Paulo
Epilepsy Surgery Program, Hospital Brigadeiro, São Paulo, SP, Brazil.
Seizure. 2009 Sep;18(7):515-8. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2009.05.003. Epub 2009 Jun 3.
Although some degree of bilateral hippocampal involvement might be frequent in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy, severe bilateral mesial temporal sclerosis (MTS) is very rare. We present our experience while treating patients with severe bilateral MTS submitted to invasive recordings.
Nine adult patients were studied. All patients had simple and complex partial seizures. All patients had bilateral independent interictal temporal lobe spiking and non-lateralizing video-EEG findings. MRI showed severe bilateral MTS and no other brain lesion. All patients had severe verbal and non-verbal memory deficits. All patients were submitted to invasive recordings after bilateral subdural grids implantation. Cortico-amygdalo-hippocampectomy (CAH) was performed in all patients on the side suggested by invasive recording. Follow-up time ranged from 5 to 10 years.
Invasive video-EEG showed exclusively unilateral seizure onset in seven patients; in two patients, seizures originating from both temporal lobes were found (80% of them originated from one side). Five patients were submitted to left and four to right CAH. Seven patients were rendered seizure-free after surgery (Engel I); the other two were rated as Engel II. There was no additional memory decline. There was no surgical morbidity or mortality. Pathological examination showed MTS in all patients.
Good surgical outcome (77% seizure-free patients) could be obtained even in this apparently unsuitable group of patients. All patients benefit from the procedure. We did not see any cognitive decline in our patients with severe bilateral MTS. Patients with severe bilateral MTS would need invasive recordings despite any findings during surface video-EEG.
尽管双侧海马一定程度的受累在颞叶癫痫患者中可能较为常见,但严重的双侧内侧颞叶硬化(MTS)却非常罕见。我们介绍了对接受侵入性记录的严重双侧MTS患者的治疗经验。
对9名成年患者进行了研究。所有患者均有单纯性和复杂性部分性发作。所有患者双侧独立出现发作间期颞叶棘波,且视频脑电图检查结果无定位意义。磁共振成像(MRI)显示严重的双侧MTS,无其他脑部病变。所有患者均有严重的言语和非言语记忆缺陷。所有患者在双侧硬膜下网格植入后接受侵入性记录。所有患者均根据侵入性记录提示的一侧进行了皮质-杏仁核-海马切除术(CAH)。随访时间为5至10年。
侵入性视频脑电图显示7例患者癫痫发作仅起源于单侧;2例患者癫痫发作起源于双侧颞叶(其中80%起源于一侧)。5例患者接受了左侧CAH,4例接受了右侧CAH。7例患者术后无癫痫发作(Engel I级);另外2例评为Engel II级。记忆无进一步减退。无手术相关并发症或死亡。病理检查显示所有患者均有MTS。
即使在这一明显不适合的患者群体中,也能获得良好的手术效果(77%的患者无癫痫发作)。所有患者均从该手术中获益。我们未发现严重双侧MTS患者有任何认知功能减退。尽管表面视频脑电图有任何发现,严重双侧MTS患者仍需要进行侵入性记录。