Hagander Louise, Harlid Richard, Svanborg Eva
Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Karolinska Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Fysiologlab in Stockholm, Stockholm, Sweden.
Chest. 2009 Aug;136(2):481-489. doi: 10.1378/chest.08-2747. Epub 2009 Jun 19.
It is not fully understood why habitual snoring frequently progresses to obstructive sleep apnea syndrome (OSAS). Vibrations per se may cause peripheral nerve lesions. Therefore, snoring vibrations could cause nervous lesions, leading to impaired reflex activation of dilating muscles at inspiration. In this study, the methodology for quantitative sensory testing in the oropharynx was developed, and the presence of sensory nerve lesions in patients with OSAS and snoring was evaluated.
Vibration detection thresholds (VDTs) and/or cold detection thresholds (CDTs) were tested at the tonsillar pillars, tongue, lip, and finger in 23 nonsnoring individuals, 13 habitual snorers (apnea-hypopnea index [AHI] < 10), and 31 patients with OSAS (AHI > 20).
At tonsillar pillars, there were significant gender differences in both VDT and CDT, with women having lower thresholds. VDT showed no significant differences between any of the three groups when men only were tested. Two nonsnoring control subjects could not detect vibrations at all. When both genders were tested, there was significant difference only between nonsnorers and patients with OSAS (p = 0.003). CDT showed significant differences between nonsnorers and snorers (p = 0.001) and also between nonsnorers and patients with OSAS (p < 0.001), but not between snorers and patients with OSAS. CDT was easier to test than VDT with low variability in nonsnorers.
CDT gave more discriminative results than VDT. Signs of sensory nervous lesions were present in the oropharynx of most patients with OSAS and some snorers, supporting the hypothesis of a progressive oropharyngeal nervous lesion. CDT testing could be a useful clinical method to evaluate the degree of oropharyngeal nervous lesions in patients who snore and in those with OSAS.
目前尚不完全清楚习惯性打鼾为何经常进展为阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停综合征(OSAS)。振动本身可能会导致周围神经病变。因此,打鼾振动可能会导致神经病变,从而导致吸气时扩张肌肉的反射激活受损。在本研究中,开发了口咽定量感觉测试方法,并评估了OSAS患者和打鼾者感觉神经病变的存在情况。
对23名不打鼾个体、13名习惯性打鼾者(呼吸暂停低通气指数[AHI]<10)和31名OSAS患者(AHI>20)在扁桃体柱、舌头、嘴唇和手指处测试振动检测阈值(VDT)和/或冷觉检测阈值(CDT)。
在扁桃体柱处,VDT和CDT均存在显著的性别差异,女性阈值较低。仅对男性进行测试时,VDT在三组之间均无显著差异。两名不打鼾的对照受试者根本无法检测到振动。对男女两性进行测试时,仅不打鼾者与OSAS患者之间存在显著差异(p = 0.003)。CDT在不打鼾者与打鼾者之间(p = 0.001)以及不打鼾者与OSAS患者之间(p < 0.001)均存在显著差异,但在打鼾者与OSAS患者之间无显著差异。对于不打鼾者,CDT比VDT更容易测试且变异性低。
CDT比VDT给出的鉴别结果更多。大多数OSAS患者和一些打鼾者的口咽存在感觉神经病变迹象,支持口咽神经病变进行性发展的假说。CDT测试可能是评估打鼾患者和OSAS患者口咽神经病变程度的一种有用的临床方法。