Kaschel Reiner
University of Osnabrueck, Germany.
Hum Psychopharmacol. 2009 Jul;24(5):345-70. doi: 10.1002/hup.1037.
Extracts of Ginkgo biloba are widely used for the treatment of cognitive impairment. Whereas reviews have focused on the question whether ginkgo is effective to enhance cognition in general, little is known about specificity of improvement. This might be crucial for future trials, thus enabling hypotheses about sensitive outcome measures. Therefore, this article summarizes such information, i.e. neuropsychological effects of chronic administration of ginkgo in healthy and cognitively impaired subjects of any age. Objective psychometric test results were considered if they reflected distinct cognitive functions from randomized controlled group-studies (RCT). We reviewed 29 RCTs yielding 209 placebo-drug comparisons of psychometric scores in four different cognitive domains comprising 14 sub-functions. Whereas little specific information can be obtained from trials for treatment of dementia, a pattern of pharmacological actions on cognitive processes emerges here from studies for mild cognitive impairment (MCI), depression, multiple sclerosis and healthy young and elderly subjects. There is consistent evidence that chronic administration improves selective attention, some executive processes and long-term memory for verbal and non-verbal material. Further trials should be more comprehensive as there are few data available on some cognitive functions and psychometric flaws in the selection of tests and the interpretation of their results favouring predominantly beta-errors. Thus, though this pattern is encouraging it also asks for a cautious interpretation to date.
银杏叶提取物被广泛用于治疗认知障碍。尽管已有综述关注银杏叶总体上是否能有效增强认知,但对于其改善的特异性却知之甚少。这对未来的试验可能至关重要,从而能够提出关于敏感结局指标的假设。因此,本文总结了此类信息,即长期给予银杏叶对任何年龄的健康和认知障碍受试者的神经心理学影响。如果客观心理测量测试结果反映了随机对照分组研究(RCT)中不同的认知功能,那么这些结果将被纳入考虑。我们回顾了29项RCT,这些研究在四个不同认知领域产生了209次安慰剂与药物的心理测量分数比较,涵盖14项子功能。虽然从治疗痴呆的试验中几乎无法获得具体信息,但从针对轻度认知障碍(MCI)、抑郁症、多发性硬化症以及健康的年轻人和老年人的研究中,可以看出银杏叶对认知过程的药理作用模式。有一致的证据表明,长期服用银杏叶可改善选择性注意力、一些执行过程以及对言语和非言语材料的长期记忆。由于关于某些认知功能的数据较少,且在测试选择和结果解释方面存在心理测量缺陷,主要有利于Ⅱ类错误,因此进一步的试验应更加全面。所以,尽管这种模式令人鼓舞,但目前仍需谨慎解读。