Poldervaart Michelle T, Breugem Corstiaan C, Speleman Lucienne, Pasmans Suzanne
Division of Pediatric Plastic Surgery, and Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Wilhelmina Children's Hospital, University Medical Center, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
J Craniofac Surg. 2009 Jul;20(4):1159-62. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0b013e3181abb249.
Lymphatic malformations (LM) are benign structural defects that can cause serious complications because of their size and location. Traditionally, surgical removal was the first treatment modality, but this could be associated with many complications and risks. Since Ogita introduced OK-432 (picibanil) in 1987 as a treatment method, this sclerosant has become popular. This paper is a review of the trials published so far on this topic.
A literature search of English trials with 5 or more patients in it with LM who had never been treated before was done. The paper had to use the microcystic-macrocystic classification and have a mean follow-up of more than a year to be included in this review. Results were classified as "excellent" when the lesions show a regression of more than 90%, "good" when regression is more than 50%, and "poor" when shrinkage is less than 50% (this also includes no response at all).
Twenty-seven percent of microcystic LMs show an excellent result; 33%, a good result; and 40%, a poor result. Of the macrocystic LMs, 88% have excellent results. Recurrence rates vary from 5% to 8%. The adverse effects are mostly mild.
Most trials have a short follow-up; therefore, there are uncertainties when it comes to cure and regression. Mostly, the adverse effects of OK-432 are trivial and disappear after a week, but the need for a temporary tracheostomy has been described. Screening for allergic reactions to penicilline is needed, with the risk of anaphylactic shock in mind. It is difficult to compare the different techniques used by the authors, and none of the trials included in this study are randomized controlled trials; most are retrospective and were so-called level 4 studies.
This review demonstrates that OK-432 is an effective way to treat LM. Because of a possible risk of airway obstruction, treatment should always take place in specialized treatment facilities. Macrocystic lesions show a better response to OK-432 treatment than microcystic lesions. Serious complications with OK-432 are infrequent, and this type of sclerotherapy seems to have no influence on future surgery. We therefore suggest the use of OK-432 as an effective first-line treatment of LMs.
淋巴管畸形(LM)是一种良性结构缺陷,因其大小和位置可导致严重并发症。传统上,手术切除是首选治疗方式,但这可能伴有许多并发症和风险。自1987年小田引入OK-432(溶链菌制剂)作为一种治疗方法以来,这种硬化剂已广受欢迎。本文是对迄今为止关于该主题已发表试验的综述。
对英文试验进行文献检索,纳入5名及以上此前未接受过治疗的淋巴管畸形患者。论文必须采用微囊型-大囊型分类法,且平均随访时间超过一年才能纳入本综述。当病变消退超过90%时,结果分类为“优秀”;消退超过50%时为“良好”;缩小小于50%(这也包括无反应)时为“差”。
27%的微囊型淋巴管畸形显示出优秀结果;33%为良好结果;40%为差结果。大囊型淋巴管畸形中,88%有优秀结果。复发率在5%至8%之间。不良反应大多轻微。
大多数试验随访时间较短;因此,在治愈和消退方面存在不确定性。大多数情况下,OK-432的不良反应轻微,一周后消失,但曾有需要临时气管切开术的描述。鉴于有过敏性休克风险,需要筛查对青霉素的过敏反应。很难比较作者使用的不同技术,本研究纳入的试验均非随机对照试验;大多数是回顾性研究,即所谓的4级研究。
本综述表明OK-432是治疗淋巴管畸形的有效方法。由于存在气道阻塞的潜在风险,治疗应始终在专业治疗机构进行。大囊型病变对OK-432治疗的反应优于微囊型病变。OK-432引起的严重并发症并不常见,这种硬化疗法似乎对未来手术没有影响。因此,我们建议将OK-432用作淋巴管畸形的有效一线治疗方法。