Kearins Olive, Walton Jackie, O'Sullivan Emma, Lawrence Gill
West Midlands Breast & Cervical Screening QA Reference Centre, West Midlands Cancer Intelligence Unit, Public Health Building, The University of Birmingham, Birmingham, B15 2TT, UK.
J Med Screen. 2009;16(2):81-4. doi: 10.1258/jms.2009.009006.
In an attempt to improve breast cancer screening uptake and coverage, persistent non-attenders in the Heart of Birmingham Teaching Primary Care Trust were included in an invitation management initiative.
Persistent non-attenders were identified in routine screening lists. Phone contact was attempted or a home visit was made. If the case was not resolved, a second appointment was made and further phone calls and home visits were attempted.
Of 548 persistent non-attenders identified, 228 (42%) declined screening, 171 (31%) attended, 72 (13%) had moved away or died, 11 (2%) were recently screened or under care for other conditions. Sixty-six cases (12%) remained unresolved. Fourteen women opted to be permanently withdrawn from the National Health Service Breast Screening Programme (NHSBSP). Twenty-four women had a negative experience of breast cancer screening (defaulted, recalled for assessment, recalled for technical reasons). No malignancies were found. A total of 1375 phone calls and 230 home visits were attempted. Uptake would have been 62.2% if none of the persistent non-attenders included in the initiative had attended for screening. With the initiative, uptake of breast cancer screening was increased to 65.3%.
Phone calls and home visits resulted in only a moderate increase in breast cancer screening uptake. The initiative encouraged nervous attenders who were reassured about the screening process. However, more women declined screening than were screened and the initiative made it easier for women to request to be permanently withdrawn from the NHSBSP.
为提高乳腺癌筛查的参与率和覆盖率,伯明翰市中心教学初级保健信托基金将持续未参加筛查者纳入邀请管理计划。
从常规筛查名单中识别出持续未参加筛查者。尝试电话联系或进行家访。如果问题未解决,则安排第二次预约,并再次尝试电话联系和家访。
在识别出的548名持续未参加筛查者中,228人(42%)拒绝筛查,171人(31%)参加了筛查,72人(13%)已搬走或去世,11人(2%)最近已接受筛查或因其他疾病正在接受治疗。66例(12%)仍未解决。14名女性选择永久退出国民健康服务乳腺癌筛查计划(NHSBSP)。24名女性在乳腺癌筛查中有负面经历(未参加、被召回评估、因技术原因被召回)。未发现恶性肿瘤。共尝试了1375次电话联系和230次家访。如果该计划中纳入的持续未参加筛查者无人参加筛查,参与率本应为62.2%。通过该计划,乳腺癌筛查的参与率提高到了65.3%。
电话联系和家访仅使乳腺癌筛查参与率适度提高。该计划鼓励了那些对筛查过程感到放心的紧张参与者。然而,拒绝筛查的女性多于接受筛查的女性,并且该计划使女性更容易请求永久退出NHSBSP。