Price Elizabeth E, Lambeth Susan P, Schapiro Steve J, Whiten Andrew
Scottish Primate Research Group, and Centre for Social Learning and Cognitive Evolution, School of Psychology, University of St Andrews, St Andrews, Fife KY16 9JP, UK.
Proc Biol Sci. 2009 Sep 22;276(1671):3377-83. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2009.0640. Epub 2009 Jul 1.
Although tool use occurs in diverse species, its complexity may mark an important distinction between humans and other animals. Chimpanzee tool use has many similarities to that seen in humans, yet evidence of the cumulatively complex and constructive technologies common in human populations remains absent in free-ranging chimpanzees. Here we provide the first evidence that chimpanzees have a latent capacity to socially learn to construct a composite tool. Fifty chimpanzees were assigned to one of five demonstration conditions that varied in the amount and type of information available in video footage of a conspecific. Chimpanzees exposed to complete footage of a chimpanzee combining the two components to retrieve a reward learned to combine the tools significantly more than those exposed to more restricted information. In a follow-up test, chimpanzees that constructed tools after watching the complete demonstration tended to do so even when the reward was within reach of the unmodified components, whereas those that spontaneously solved the task (without seeing the modification process) combined only when necessary. Social learning, therefore, had a powerful effect in instilling a marked persistence in the use of a complex technique at the cost of efficiency, inhibiting insightful tool use.
尽管工具使用在多种物种中都有出现,但其复杂性可能标志着人类与其他动物之间的一个重要区别。黑猩猩使用工具与人类有许多相似之处,然而,在自由放养的黑猩猩中,仍然缺乏人类群体中常见的累积性复杂和建设性技术的证据。在这里,我们提供了第一个证据,表明黑猩猩具有通过社会学习构建复合工具的潜在能力。五十只黑猩猩被分配到五个示范条件之一,这些条件在同种个体视频片段中可用信息的数量和类型上有所不同。接触到一只黑猩猩将两个部件组合起来以获取奖励的完整视频片段的黑猩猩,比接触到更有限信息的黑猩猩更能学会组合工具。在后续测试中,观看完整示范后构建工具的黑猩猩,即使奖励在未修改部件可触及的范围内,也倾向于这样做,而那些自发解决任务(未看到修改过程)的黑猩猩只在必要时才进行组合。因此,社会学习在灌输对复杂技术的显著坚持方面具有强大作用,代价是效率,抑制了有洞察力的工具使用。