Riedel Charlotte Tandrup, Brøndsted Lone, Rosenquist Hanne, Haxgart Sine Nygaard, Christensen Bjarke Bak
Department of Microbiology and Risk Assessment, National Food Institute, Technical University of Denmark, Mørkhøj Bygade 26, 2860 Søborg, Denmark.
J Food Prot. 2009 Jun;72(6):1173-80. doi: 10.4315/0362-028x-72.6.1173.
This study evaluated the effectiveness of 11 chemical compounds to reduce Campylobacter jejuni on chicken skin and meat samples dipped in chemical solutions. Treatment of skin samples for 1 min using tartaric acid (2%) and caprylic acid sodium salt (5%) caused reductions of C. jejuni NCTC11168, which were not significantly different from the reduction obtained by sterile water (0.95 log). Statistically larger reductions (1.57 to 3.81 log) were caused by formic acid (2%), lactic acid (2.5%), trisodium phosphate (10%), capric acid sodium salt (5%), grapefruit seed extract (1.6%), and chlorhexidine diacetate salt hydrate (1%). The most effective compounds were cetylpyridinium chloride (0.5%) and benzalkonium chloride (1%) (>4.2 log). However, when these treated samples were stored for 24 h at 5 degrees C, cetylpyridinium chloride, benzalkonium chloride, and grapefruit seed extract were less effective, indicating that some cells may recover after a 1-min treatment with these chemicals. An increase in treatment time to 15 min resulted in higher effectiveness of trisodium phosphate and formic acid. Interestingly, when reduction of the C. jejuni population was compared on chicken skin and meat, sterile water and lactic acid caused considerably larger reductions on skin than on meat, whereas the opposite was seen for caprylic acid sodium salt. In conclusion, this study has identified chemicals with substantial reduction effects on C. jejuni. The analysis has further emphasized that treatment time and food matrix affect the outcome in an unpredictable manner and, therefore, detailed studies are needed to evaluate the reduction effectiveness of chemicals.
本研究评估了11种化合物对浸泡在化学溶液中的鸡肉皮和肉样中降低空肠弯曲菌数量的有效性。用酒石酸(2%)和辛酸钠盐(5%)处理皮肤样本1分钟,可使空肠弯曲菌NCTC11168数量减少,与用无菌水处理(0.95个对数)所获得的减少量无显著差异。甲酸(2%)、乳酸(2.5%)、磷酸三钠(10%)、癸酸钠盐(5%)、葡萄柚籽提取物(1.6%)和二醋酸氯己定盐水合物(1%)可使细菌数量有统计学意义的更大减少(1.57至3.81个对数)。最有效的化合物是十六烷基氯化吡啶(0.5%)和苯扎氯铵(1%)(>4.2个对数)。然而,当这些处理过的样本在5℃下储存24小时后,十六烷基氯化吡啶、苯扎氯铵和葡萄柚籽提取物的效果变差,这表明用这些化学物质处理1分钟后,一些细胞可能会恢复。将处理时间延长至15分钟可提高磷酸三钠和甲酸的有效性。有趣的是,当比较空肠弯曲菌在鸡肉皮和肉上数量的减少情况时,无菌水和乳酸对皮肤的减少作用比对肉的减少作用大得多,而辛酸钠盐的情况则相反。总之,本研究确定了对空肠弯曲菌有显著减少作用的化学物质。分析进一步强调,处理时间和食物基质对结果有不可预测的影响,因此,需要进行详细研究来评估化学物质的减少有效性。