Hargreave F E, Nair P
Department of Medicine, Firestone Institute for Respiratory Health, St. Joseph's Healthcare, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
Clin Exp Allergy. 2009 Nov;39(11):1652-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2222.2009.03321.x. Epub 2009 Jul 20.
The diagnosis of asthma depends on what we mean by the word. Its definition continues to be controversial because there is no single genetic or environmental cause. Addressed from a descriptive point of view, the disease components include airway inflammation, symptoms, variable airflow limitation and chronic airflow limitation. The essentialist definition conveys the message that asthma is a separate disease entity, fails to identify a primary defining characteristic which separates it from other diseases and is long winded. These disadvantages are overcome by the nominalist definition of asthma in which the word 'asthma'refers to an abnormality of airway function, specifically to wide variations in airflow limitation over short periods of time. In patients with asthma the other components of airway disease need to be considered. These have separate nominalist definitions and especially include different types of bronchitis for airway inflammation and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease for chronic airflow limitation. What is present will vary between and within patients. The accurate diagnosis of asthma and of other components of disease all require objective measurements. Currently spirometry and airway responsiveness should be available to the general practitioner, who sees milder disease, and additional quantitative sputum cell counts in specialist practice, where moderate to severe disease is more prevalent. Such measurements characterize the patient, identify heterogeneity and allow treatment to be personalized.
哮喘的诊断取决于我们对这个词的理解。其定义一直存在争议,因为不存在单一的遗传或环境病因。从描述的角度来看,该疾病的组成部分包括气道炎症、症状、可变气流受限和慢性气流受限。本质主义定义传达出哮喘是一种独立疾病实体的信息,但未能确定将其与其他疾病区分开来的主要定义特征,而且表述冗长。哮喘的唯名论定义克服了这些缺点,在该定义中,“哮喘”一词指气道功能异常,具体而言是指短时间内气流受限的广泛变化。对于哮喘患者,需要考虑气道疾病的其他组成部分。这些部分有各自的唯名论定义,尤其包括用于气道炎症的不同类型支气管炎以及用于慢性气流受限的慢性阻塞性肺疾病。不同患者之间以及同一患者体内存在的情况各不相同。哮喘及疾病其他组成部分的准确诊断都需要客观测量。目前,肺活量测定和气道反应性检测应该可供诊治较轻疾病的全科医生使用,而在诊治中度至重度疾病更为普遍的专科实践中,还应进行额外的定量痰细胞计数。这些测量能够对患者进行特征描述,识别异质性,并使治疗能够个性化。