Ahn Byeong-Cheol, Kim Hae-Joo, Lee Sang-Woo, Yoo Jeongsoo, Choi Jae-Kap, Lee Jaetae
Department of Nuclear Medicine, School of Medicine, Kyungpook National University, Daegu 700-721, South Korea.
Ann Nucl Med. 2009 Sep;23(7):651-6. doi: 10.1007/s12149-009-0287-8. Epub 2009 Jul 22.
Quantitative bone SPECT studies have several advantages over qualitative studies for evaluating a temporomandibular joint (TMJ), yet in certain cases additional images are still needed. Accordingly, the current study developed a new easy SPECT quantification method for the bone tracer uptake in a TMJ and evaluated its usefulness and inter-observer variability in patients with TMJ pain.
Sixty-six adult patients (11 males, 55 females) with a mean age of 31 years (range 22-79 years) suffering from TMJ pain were questioned regarding the history of their condition, and then subjected to an oromaxillofacial examination and bone SPECT. New quantitative data for TMJs (TMJ index) were calculated from a formula using TMJ and skull counts.
TMJs with spontaneous pain had higher TMJ indices than those without spontaneous pain (8.87 vs. 6.87, P = 0.032). TMJs with mouth-opening pain or palpatory pain also exhibited higher TMJ indices than those without such pains, although the differences were not statistically significant. Positive TMJs, according to a visual SPECT interpretation, had much higher TMJ indices than the negative ones (8.99 vs. 5.37, P < 0.001). The reference skull count, mean TMJ count and TMJ index obtained using the proposed TMJ quantification method demonstrated an excellent correlation based on two independent observers (r = 0.996, r = 0.993 and r = 0.989, respectively; P < 0.001).
The current results indicate that the proposed quantitative TMJ bone SPECT is easy to perform, plus the resulting TMJ index has a lower inter-observer variability, making it an effective TMJ evaluation method for patients with painful TMJs, and especially useful for serial studies.
在评估颞下颌关节(TMJ)方面,定量骨SPECT研究相较于定性研究具有若干优势,但在某些情况下仍需要额外的图像。因此,本研究开发了一种新的简便SPECT定量方法,用于测量TMJ中骨示踪剂的摄取,并评估其在TMJ疼痛患者中的实用性和观察者间变异性。
对66例平均年龄31岁(范围22 - 79岁)的成年TMJ疼痛患者(11例男性,55例女性)进行病史询问,然后进行口腔颌面检查和骨SPECT检查。使用TMJ和颅骨计数,通过公式计算TMJ的新定量数据(TMJ指数)。
有自发痛的TMJ的TMJ指数高于无自发痛的TMJ(8.87对6.87,P = 0.032)。有张口痛或触压痛的TMJ的TMJ指数也高于无此类疼痛的TMJ,尽管差异无统计学意义。根据SPECT视觉解读为阳性的TMJ的TMJ指数远高于阴性TMJ(8.99对5.37,P < 0.001)。基于两名独立观察者,使用所提出的TMJ定量方法获得的参考颅骨计数、平均TMJ计数和TMJ指数显示出极佳的相关性(分别为r = 0.996、r = 0.993和r = 0.989;P < 0.001)。
目前的结果表明,所提出的定量TMJ骨SPECT易于实施,并且所得的TMJ指数具有较低的观察者间变异性,使其成为评估疼痛性TMJ患者的有效方法,尤其适用于系列研究。