Cooper S J, Lovatt T J
Immunology Department, New Cross Hospital, The Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust, Wolverhampton.
Br J Biomed Sci. 2009;66(2):79-84. doi: 10.1080/09674845.2009.11730249.
Coeliac screening is one of the most frequently requested investigations in immunology laboratories. This study evaluates seven commercial anti-tissue transglutaminase (tTG) enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kits across a varied population of 80 routine samples received for coeliac screening. This investigation assesses whether or not absorbance levels can be used to detect low serum IgA and whether or not raised IgA concentrations can interfere with IgA-tTG results. Sensitivity and specificity varied hugely and four out of the seven methods required cut-off value modification to attain 100% sensitivity with endomysial testing. Four of the seven kits identified low IgA samples with greater than 90% accuracy, but sensitivity dropped to 75% in others. All the kits were affected by raised serum IgA concentrations, leading to false-positive results. There was notable variation between the seven kits in respect of high IgA concentrations and positive IgA-tTG results, with concordance analysis indicating a weak linear relationship between IgA concentration and tTG value. This study concludes that there is significant variability between the commercial tTG assays in the diagnostic market. Laboratories should be aware of their kit's limitations and may need to adjust cut-off values to maximise sensitivity. It is possible to identify IgA deficiency from the tTG values, but the ability to do this varies between manufacturers. Raised IgA levels continue to affect the specificity of IgA-tTG assays and interference by polyclonal and monoclonal IgA should be considered in samples with positive tTG and negative endomysial results.
乳糜泻筛查是免疫实验室中最常被要求进行的检测项目之一。本研究评估了七种商用抗组织转谷氨酰胺酶(tTG)酶联免疫吸附测定(ELISA)试剂盒,这些试剂盒用于检测80份因乳糜泻筛查而接收的常规样本,样本群体各异。该研究评估吸光度水平是否可用于检测低血清IgA,以及升高的IgA浓度是否会干扰IgA - tTG检测结果。灵敏度和特异性差异极大,七种方法中有四种需要修改临界值才能在进行肌内膜检测时达到100%的灵敏度。七种试剂盒中有四种以高于90%的准确率识别出低IgA样本,但其他试剂盒的灵敏度降至75%。所有试剂盒均受到血清IgA浓度升高的影响,导致假阳性结果。七种试剂盒在高IgA浓度和阳性IgA - tTG结果方面存在显著差异,一致性分析表明IgA浓度与tTG值之间呈弱线性关系。本研究得出结论,诊断市场上的商用tTG检测方法存在显著差异。实验室应了解其试剂盒的局限性,可能需要调整临界值以最大化灵敏度。可以从tTG值中识别出IgA缺乏,但不同制造商的识别能力有所不同。升高的IgA水平继续影响IgA - tTG检测的特异性,对于tTG阳性而肌内膜检测结果为阴性的样本,应考虑多克隆和单克隆IgA的干扰。