Chia Benjamin, Catalano Louis W, Glickel Steven Z, Barron O Alton, Meier Kristen
C.V. Starr Hand Surgery Center, St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hospital, New York, NY 10019, USA.
J Hand Surg Am. 2009 Jul-Aug;34(6):1014-20. doi: 10.1016/j.jhsa.2009.04.004.
Closed reduction and percutaneous pinning is a reliable technique for treating 2- and 3-part distal radius fractures. There are currently no data that demonstrate the proximity of at-risk nerves and tendons during percutaneous placement of 5 commonly used K-wires. Whereas the previous literature notes the risk of superficial radial nerve injury with K-wire insertion into the radial styloid, the current study provides specific distances, not only to the superficial radial nerve (SRN) but also to the tendons of the first through fifth extensor compartments during K-wire insertion.
K-wires (1.5 mm or 0.059 in) were placed percutaneously into the distal radius of 15 cadaver specimens, simulating fixation of a distal radius fracture. After dissection, the distance from the K-wires to the extensor tendons and branches of the SRN were measured and tabulated.
The volar radial styloid K-wire was an average distance of 1.47 mm +/- 1.7 from the closest branch of the SRN. One penetrated a branch of the SRN. The dorsal radial styloid K-wire was an average distance of 0.35 mm +/- 0.64 from the closest branch of the SRN. No tendons in the first compartment were found penetrated by or touching the K-wires. The transverse radial K-wire was an average distance of 1.07 mm +/- 1.57 from the branches or trunk of the SRN. One K-wire was found piercing the volar branch of the SRN, and 1 K-wire was found piercing the abductor pollicis longus. The dorsal rim K-wire was an average of 2.94 mm +/- 2.11 from the ulnar aspect of the extensor pollicis longus and an average of 1.44 mm +/- 1.65 from the radial aspect of the extensor digitorum communis. The dorsoulnar K-wire was an average distance of 1.88 mm +/- 1.6 ulnar or radial to the extensor digiti quinti proprius and penetrated it in three specimens.
The volar radial styloid, transverse radial, and dorsoulnar K-wires all penetrated either tendons or nerves. It is therefore prudent to make a small incision to identify and protect the underlying structures prior to placement of K-wires used for the fixation of distal radius fractures. Also, care must be taken not to place the dorsal K-wires more than 5 mm ulnar to Lister's tubercle to avoid extensor digitorum communis injury.
闭合复位经皮穿针固定术是治疗桡骨远端二部分和三部分骨折的可靠技术。目前尚无数据表明在经皮置入5种常用克氏针时,危险神经和肌腱的接近程度。尽管先前的文献指出克氏针插入桡骨茎突时有桡神经浅支损伤的风险,但本研究提供了具体距离,不仅是克氏针到桡神经浅支(SRN)的距离,还有克氏针插入时到第一至第五伸肌间隔肌腱的距离。
将克氏针(1.5毫米或0.059英寸)经皮置入15个尸体标本的桡骨远端,模拟桡骨远端骨折的固定。解剖后,测量并记录克氏针到伸肌腱和SRN分支的距离。
掌侧桡骨茎突克氏针到SRN最近分支的平均距离为1.47毫米±1.7毫米。有一根穿透了SRN的一个分支。背侧桡骨茎突克氏针到SRN最近分支的平均距离为0.35毫米±0.64毫米。未发现第一间隔内的肌腱被克氏针穿透或接触。横向桡骨克氏针到SRN分支或主干的平均距离为1.07毫米±1.57毫米。发现一根克氏针穿透SRN的掌侧分支,一根克氏针穿透拇长展肌。背侧边缘克氏针到拇长伸肌尺侧的平均距离为2.94毫米±2.11毫米,到指总伸肌桡侧的平均距离为1.44毫米±1.65毫米。背尺侧克氏针到小指固有伸肌尺侧或桡侧的平均距离为1.88毫米±1.6毫米,在三个标本中穿透了该肌腱。
掌侧桡骨茎突、横向桡骨和背尺侧克氏针均穿透了肌腱或神经。因此,在置入用于固定桡骨远端骨折的克氏针之前,谨慎的做法是做一个小切口以识别并保护深层结构。此外,必须注意不要将背侧克氏针置于Lister结节尺侧超过5毫米处,以避免指总伸肌损伤。