Edwards Lily N, Sorkin Andrew E, Rhodes Richard C, Petersson Katherine H
Department of Fisheries, Animal and Veterinary Science, University of Rhode Island, Kingston, Rhode Island 02881, USA.
Zoo Biol. 2010 Jul-Aug;29(4):416-31. doi: 10.1002/zoo.20264.
The purpose of this study was to identify efficient sampling methods for establishing accurate activity budgets for zoo animals. Seven cotton-top tamarins (Saguinus oedipus) from two zoos were videotaped for multiple 90 min sessions, 3 to 4 days per week for 12 weeks. An activity budget was constructed for each animal using a continuous sampling method to analyze 30 hr of video recording of each animal. These master datasets, reflecting actual behavior, were re-sampled using interval sampling lengths of 0.25, 0.5, 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 10, 15 and 20 min, and cluster sampling protocols (periodic sessions of continuous sampling) of 10 min x 3, 15 min x 2, 20 min x 1, 15 min x 1 and 10 min x 1 (min x repetitions/90 min sample period) to construct additional activity budgets for each animal. The Canberra similarity index was used to determine the statistical relationship between these activity budgets and those based on the master datasets. As interval length increased, there was a consequent decrease in the accuracy of the associated activity budgets as compared with the master dataset. No cluster sampling protocols yielded activity budgets as accurate as the four shortest interval lengths, but all cluster sampling protocols were more accurate than the three longest interval lengths. All the tested protocols varied in ability to accurately portray animal behavior. Overall, interval sampling provided superior behavioral representations at lower observer input. Results from this study will potentially facilitate the standardization of behavior monitoring protocols at zoos.
本研究的目的是确定有效的采样方法,以便为动物园动物建立准确的活动预算。对来自两个动物园的七只棉顶狨(Saguinus oedipus)进行了多次90分钟时段的录像,每周3至4天,共12周。使用连续采样方法为每只动物构建活动预算,以分析每只动物30小时的视频记录。这些反映实际行为的主数据集,使用0.25、0.5、1、2、4、5、7、10、15和20分钟的间隔采样长度,以及10分钟×3、15分钟×2、20分钟×1、15分钟×1和10分钟×1(分钟×重复次数/90分钟采样时段)的整群采样方案(连续采样的定期时段)进行重新采样,为每只动物构建额外的活动预算。使用堪培拉相似性指数来确定这些活动预算与基于主数据集的活动预算之间的统计关系。随着间隔长度的增加,与主数据集相比,相关活动预算的准确性随之降低。没有整群采样方案产生的活动预算与四个最短间隔长度一样准确,但所有整群采样方案都比三个最长间隔长度更准确。所有测试方案在准确描绘动物行为的能力上各不相同。总体而言,间隔采样在较低的观察者投入下提供了更好的行为表征。本研究的结果可能会促进动物园行为监测方案的标准化。