University of Barcelona Dental School, Barcelona, Spain.
Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2009 Nov;38(11):1184-7. doi: 10.1016/j.ijom.2009.06.023. Epub 2009 Aug 5.
Panoramic radiographs are the most widely used radiological diagnostic technique in dental practice, offering full vision of the maxillas and adjacent regions, but there are shortcomings regarding detailed dentoalveolar exploration. This study compared the precision of digital versus conventional panoramic radiographs in the presurgical evaluation of impacted lower third molars. 390 mandibular third molars were studied in 287 patients; their position, morphology and surgical technique used were recorded. 84 molars were evaluated with digital panoramic radiographs, and 306 with conventional panoramic radiographs. Four observers compared the presurgical data with the surgical findings and the diagnostic precision was established. There were statistically significant differences between the techniques; digital panoramic radiographs were more precise than conventional radiographs in providing the correct presurgical evaluation of the impacted third molars. Surgeon experience had a statistically significant influence on planning the presurgical study. Panoramic radiographs distort the position and morphology of the lower third molar, which may affect the presurgical strategy used. In this context, and because of their lesser experience, first year residents consider the operation to be more complicated, and tend to act less conservatively and cause increased trauma. In conclusion, digital panoramic radiographs offer significantly greater diagnostic precision than conventional panoramic radiographs.
曲面体层片是口腔医学中最常用的放射学诊断技术,可全面观察上颌骨及邻近区域,但在详细的牙牙槽探索方面存在不足。本研究比较了数字化与传统曲面体层片在下颌阻生第三磨牙术前评估中的精确性。研究纳入了 287 名患者的 390 颗下颌第三磨牙,记录了其位置、形态和手术技术。84 颗磨牙采用数字化曲面体层片进行评估,306 颗采用传统曲面体层片进行评估。四位观察者将术前数据与手术结果进行比较,并确定了诊断精度。两种技术之间存在统计学差异;数字化曲面体层片在提供正确的下颌阻生第三磨牙术前评估方面比传统曲面体层片更精确。外科医生的经验对术前研究的规划有统计学意义的影响。曲面体层片会扭曲下颌第三磨牙的位置和形态,这可能会影响术前策略的选择。在这种情况下,由于经验较少,第一年住院医师认为手术更为复杂,往往不那么保守,造成更多的创伤。总之,数字化曲面体层片提供的诊断精度明显高于传统曲面体层片。