Viteva Ekaterina I, Zahariev Zahari I
Department of Neurology, Medical University, Plovdiv, Bulgaria.
Folia Med (Plovdiv). 2009 Apr-Jun;51(2):33-9.
In pseudorefractory epilepsy (20% of the cases diagnosed with refractory epilepsy) the factors responsible for triggering the seizures are extraneous to epilepsy and the seizures can be controlled after diagnostic and therapeutic re-evaluation.
To determine the factors causing development of pseudoresistance in patients with epilepsy.
Detailed case histories of 191 patients with a diagnosis of drug-resistant epilepsy were collected; the medical records were analyzed retrospectively. Thirty-nine patient (20.42%) were found to be with pseudorefractory epilepsy. The patients were classified by demographic criteria and specific clinical signs, and by laboratory findings.
The patients (age range 18 to 72 years, mean duration of disease 27 years) presented with partial (56.41%), generalized (43.59%) and polymorphic seizures (17.95%) with a higher relative percentage of the patients with symptomatic (41.03%) and cryptogenic (35.9%) epilepsy. The main groups of factors that determined pseudoresistance were diagnostic (46.15%) and therapeutic errors (69.23%), poor compliance (33.33%), external factors (5.12%), as well as a combination of these (53.84%). We found that compliance correlated weakly with age and education, but showed high and moderate correlation with duration of epilepsy less than 20 years and male gender. Therapy adjustment had a beneficial effect in 16 of 24 patients (66.67%) in our study.
The detailed analysis of the causes for pseudoresistance focuses on some pitfalls of the diagnostic and therapeutic process, compliance of the patient and influence of external factors aiming at reduction of the number of cases with pseudorefractory epilepsy and achieving more favourable clinical effect of treatment.
在假性难治性癫痫(占难治性癫痫诊断病例的20%)中,引发癫痫发作的因素与癫痫本身无关,在进行诊断和治疗重新评估后,癫痫发作可得到控制。
确定癫痫患者出现假性耐药的原因。
收集了191例诊断为药物难治性癫痫患者的详细病史;对病历进行回顾性分析。发现39例患者(20.42%)为假性难治性癫痫。根据人口统计学标准、特定临床体征以及实验室检查结果对患者进行分类。
患者年龄范围为18至72岁,平均病程27年,表现为部分性发作(56.41%)、全身性发作(43.59%)和多形性发作(17.95%),症状性癫痫(41.03%)和隐源性癫痫(35.9%)患者的相对比例较高。决定假性耐药的主要因素类别包括诊断错误(46.15%)、治疗错误(69.23%)、依从性差(33.33%)、外部因素(5.12%)以及这些因素的组合(53.84%)。我们发现依从性与年龄和教育程度的相关性较弱,但与癫痫病程小于20年以及男性性别呈高度和中度相关。在我们的研究中,24例患者中有16例(66.67%)通过调整治疗取得了有益效果。
对假性耐药原因的详细分析聚焦于诊断和治疗过程中的一些陷阱、患者的依从性以及外部因素的影响,旨在减少假性难治性癫痫病例数量并取得更有利的临床治疗效果。