Schroeder Ariel, Schroeder Maryellen A, D'Amico Frank
St. Joseph's High School, Natrona Heights, PA, USA.
J Fam Pract. 2009 Aug;58(8):404-9.
Studies have shown that rubbing alcohol pads on stethoscope diaphragms can reduce bacterial colonization, but alcohol pads are used infrequently used and not always available.
We conducted a prospective, single-blinded study to investigate whether simultaneously scrubbing hands and stethoscope head with alcohol-based hand foam would significantly reduce bacterial counts on the stethoscope. Using their own stethoscope, participants imprinted the stethoscope head onto a chocolate agar plate, then used alcohol-based hand foam to cleanse their hands while simultaneously rubbing the stethoscope head. Once the stethoscope heads were dry, the participants imprinted their stethoscope heads onto a second plate. After 48 hours' incubation, we determined the bacterial counts for the prewash and post-wash plates, and compared the 2.
We analyzed a total of 184 cultures (from 92 stethoscopes). Both the mean (28 prewash vs 3 post-wash, P=.001) and median (11 prewash vs 1 post-wash, P=.001) colony counts were significantly greater before being cleansed. Three methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) colonies were identified in the prewash period; all were destroyed by the foam. The estimated number of hand washes needed to prevent 1 MRSA colony is 31 (95% confidence interval [CI], 18-89).
Simultaneously using hand foam to clean hands and stethoscope heads reduces bacterial counts on stethoscopes. Further research is needed to determine whether this intervention can reduce morbidity and mortality associated with bacterial infection.
研究表明,用酒精棉片擦拭听诊器膜片可减少细菌定植,但酒精棉片使用频率不高且并非随时可用。
我们进行了一项前瞻性单盲研究,以调查用含酒精的洗手液同时清洗双手和听诊器头部是否能显著减少听诊器上的细菌数量。参与者使用自己的听诊器,将听诊器头部按压在巧克力琼脂平板上,然后用含酒精的洗手液洗手,同时擦拭听诊器头部。听诊器头部干燥后,参与者将其再次按压在另一平板上。培养48小时后,我们确定清洗前后平板上的细菌数量,并进行比较。
我们共分析了184份培养物(来自92个听诊器)。清洗前的平均菌落数(28个)和中位数菌落数(11个)均显著高于清洗后(分别为3个和1个,P = 0.001)。清洗前阶段鉴定出3个耐甲氧西林金黄色葡萄球菌(MRSA)菌落;所有这些菌落在清洗过程中均被洗手液消灭。预防1个MRSA菌落所需的洗手次数估计为31次(95%置信区间[CI],18 - 89)。
用洗手液同时清洗双手和听诊器头部可减少听诊器上的细菌数量。需要进一步研究以确定这种干预措施是否能降低与细菌感染相关的发病率和死亡率。