Teitelbaum Ana P, Pochapski Márcia T, Jansen Jocélia L, Sabbagh-Haddad Aida, Santos Fábio A, Czlusniak Gislaine D
Department of Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Ponta Grossa State University, Ponta Grossa, Paraná, Brazil.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2009 Oct;37(5):463-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0528.2009.00488.x. Epub 2009 Jul 22.
To evaluate the mechanical and chemical control of dental biofilm in patients with Down syndrome, using different experimental dentifrices.
Forty institutionalized children between ages 7 and 13 years in the mixed dentition phase participated in this study. An experimental cross-over, blind clinical trial was used, having the following protocols: fluoridated dentifrice (protocol G1); fluoridated dentifrice + chlorhexidine (protocol G2); fluoridated dentifrice + chlorhexidine + plaque-disclosing agent (protocol G3); and fluoridated dentifrice + plaque-disclosing agent (protocol G4). Each experimental stage lasted 10 days with a 15-day washout. The evaluated parameters were Plaque Index and gingival bleeding.
The initial clinical conditions between each stage were similar. Statistical differences were observed (P < 0.001) for the clinical conditions evaluated before and after the treatments. The dentifrices containing plaque-disclosing agent, irrespective of their association with chlorhexidine, produced a greater reduction in the final plaque index. As for gingival bleeding, the dentifrice containing erythrosine and the one containing chlorhexidine produced similar results. The dentifrice containing an association of chlorhexidine and erythrosine gave the best results.
With the methodology employed, it was possible to conclude that the combination of drugs (chlorhexidine, fluorine and erythrosine) within one dentifrice can be useful in controlling dental biofilm and in the reduction of gingival bleeding.
使用不同的实验性牙膏评估唐氏综合征患者牙菌斑的机械和化学控制效果。
40名年龄在7至13岁处于混合牙列期的机构化儿童参与了本研究。采用实验性交叉、盲法临床试验,有以下方案:含氟牙膏(方案G1);含氟牙膏+氯己定(方案G2);含氟牙膏+氯己定+菌斑显示剂(方案G3);含氟牙膏+菌斑显示剂(方案G4)。每个实验阶段持续10天,有15天的洗脱期。评估参数为菌斑指数和牙龈出血情况。
各阶段之间的初始临床状况相似。治疗前后评估的临床状况存在统计学差异(P<0.001)。含菌斑显示剂的牙膏,无论是否与氯己定联合使用,最终菌斑指数的降低幅度更大。至于牙龈出血情况,含赤藓红的牙膏和含氯己定的牙膏产生了相似的结果。含氯己定和赤藓红联合的牙膏效果最佳。
采用该方法可以得出结论,一种牙膏中药物(氯己定、氟和赤藓红)的组合有助于控制牙菌斑和减少牙龈出血。