Bitran Marcela, Zúñiga Denisse, Flotts Paulina, Padilla Oslando, Moreno Rodrigo
Centro de Educación Médica, Escuela de Medicina, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile.
Rev Med Chil. 2009 May;137(5):617-24. Epub 2009 Jul 17.
Despite being among the best academically prepared of the country, many medical students have difficulties to communicate in writing. In 2005, the School of Medicine at the Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile introduced a writing workshop in the undergraduate curriculum, to enhance the students' writing skills.
To describe the workshop and its impact on the writing skills of 3 cohorts of students.
This 30-h workshop used a participative methodology with emphasis on deliberate practice and feedback. Students worked in small groups with a faculty member specially trained in writing. The qualities of the essays written before and after the workshop were compared. Essays were rated by a professional team that used an analytic rubric to measure formal aspects of text writing as well as more complex thinking processes.
There was a significant improvement in the quality of the texts written after the workshop; the main changes occurred in argumentation, and in paragraph and text structure. This improvement was inversely proportional to the initial level of performance, and independent of gender.
A writing workshop based on deliberate practice and personalized feedback is effective to enhance the writing proficiency of medical students. Due to its design, this workshop could be useful for students of other careers and universities.
尽管智利天主教大学医学院的许多学生在学术准备方面处于国内顶尖水平,但他们在书面交流方面仍存在困难。2005年,该校医学院在本科课程中引入了写作工作坊,以提高学生的写作技能。
描述该工作坊及其对三组学生写作技能的影响。
这个30小时的工作坊采用参与式方法,强调刻意练习和反馈。学生们以小组形式与一位经过专门写作培训的教员合作。比较了工作坊前后所写论文的质量。论文由一个专业团队评分,该团队使用分析性评分标准来衡量文本写作的形式方面以及更复杂的思维过程。
工作坊后所写文本的质量有显著提高;主要变化发生在论证、段落和文本结构方面。这种提高与初始表现水平成反比,且与性别无关。
基于刻意练习和个性化反馈的写作工作坊对于提高医学生的写作水平是有效的。由于其设计,这个工作坊可能对其他专业和大学的学生有用。