Buesch Francisca Eugster, Schlaepfer Barbara, de Bruin Eling D, Wohlrab Gabriela, Ammann-Reiffer Corinne, Meyer-Heim Andreas
Rehabilitation Centre Affoltern am Albis, University Children's Hospital, ETH, Zurich, Switzerland.
Int J Rehabil Res. 2010 Jun;33(2):187-92. doi: 10.1097/MRR.0b013e3283310d6e.
The objective of this pilot study was to investigate the feasibility of constraint-induced movement therapy (CIMT) in children with obstetric brachial plexus palsy and receive preliminary information about functional improvements. Two patients (age 12 years) with obstetric brachial plexus palsy were included for a 126-h home-based CIMT intervention (3 and 4.5 weeks) and weekly monitored with the Melbourne Assessment of Unilateral Upper Limb function and the Nine-hole Peg Test. The Assisted Hand Assessment was performed 3 weeks before the beginning of intervention, preintervention, postintervention, and at 3 weeks follow-up (ABA single-case design). Tests were analyzed descriptively, visually, and where possible, using a time series analysis with C statistic. Results revealed changes of arm function in both patients between preintervention and follow-up test as follows: Assisted Hand Assessment from 85 to 92% in patient A and 80 to 89% in patient B, in the Melbourne Assessment of Unilateral Upper Limb function from 87 to 90% (C=0.578, z=1.876, P<0.05) in patient A and 72 to 80% (C=0.827, z=2.68, P<0.005) in patient B. There was no improvement in the Nine-hole Peg Test in both patients. Improvements as a result of CIMT found in this pilot study may not be considered substantial. However, they justify further research as some findings indicate relationship to the CIMT intervention in the 'B' phase. To enhance motivation and to plan a controlled, randomized clinical trial, child-friendly applications of the CIMT concept and adequate measures to monitor compliance are being discussed.
这项初步研究的目的是调查强制性运动疗法(CIMT)对产瘫性臂丛神经麻痹患儿的可行性,并获取有关功能改善的初步信息。两名产瘫性臂丛神经麻痹患儿(12岁)接受了为期126小时的家庭式CIMT干预(3周和4.5周),并每周通过墨尔本单上肢功能评估和九孔插钉测试进行监测。在干预开始前3周、干预前、干预后以及随访3周时进行辅助手评估(ABA单病例设计)。对测试结果进行描述性、直观分析,并在可能的情况下,使用带有C统计量的时间序列分析。结果显示,两名患者在干预前和随访测试之间的手臂功能变化如下:患者A的辅助手评估从85%提高到92%,患者B从80%提高到89%;在墨尔本单上肢功能评估中,患者A从87%提高到90%(C=0.578,z=1.876,P<0.05),患者B从72%提高到80%(C=0.827,z=2.68,P<0.005)。两名患者的九孔插钉测试均未改善。在这项初步研究中发现的CIMT带来的改善可能不算显著。然而,由于一些研究结果表明在“B”阶段与CIMT干预存在关联,这些改善结果证明有必要进一步研究。为了提高积极性并计划进行一项对照随机临床试验,正在讨论如何以儿童友好的方式应用CIMT概念以及采取适当措施监测依从性。