Department of Neurology, Assiut University Hospital, Assiut, Egypt.
Eur J Neurol. 2009 Dec;16(12):1323-30. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-1331.2009.02746.x. Epub 2009 Sep 23.
The purpose of this study was to compare the long-term effect of five daily sessions of 1 vs. 3 Hz repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) on motor recovery in acute stroke.
A total of 36 patients with acute ischaemic stroke participated in the study. The patients were randomly assigned into one of three groups; the first and second groups received real rTMS; 1 and 3 Hz and third group received sham stimulation, daily for 5 days. Motor disability was assessed before and after the last session, and then after first, second and third month. Cortical excitability was assessed before and after the second and fifth session. The outcome measure was clinical disability at 3 months post-rTMS.
No significant differences were found in basal rating scales between the three groups. At the 3-month time point, both of the real rTMS groups had improved significantly more in different rating scales than the sham group; in addition, the 1 Hz group performed better than the 3 Hz group. Measures of cortical excitability immediately after the last session showed that the 1 Hz group had reduced excitability of the non-stroke hemisphere and increased excitability of the stroke hemisphere, whereas the 3 Hz group only showed increased excitability of the stroke hemisphere.
These results confirm that five daily sessions of rTMS over motor cortex using either 1 Hz over the unaffected hemisphere or 3 Hz over the affected hemisphere can enhance recovery. At 3 months, the improvement was more pronounced in 1 Hz group.
本研究旨在比较五次每日 1 赫兹与 3 赫兹重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)对急性脑卒中运动功能恢复的长期影响。
共 36 例急性缺血性脑卒中患者参与本研究。患者随机分为三组;第一组和第二组接受真 rTMS,1 赫兹和 3 赫兹;第三组接受假刺激,每天一次,共 5 天。在最后一次治疗前后、第一次、第二次和第三次治疗后评估运动障碍。皮质兴奋性在第二次和第五次治疗前后评估。结局测量为 rTMS 后 3 个月的临床残疾。
三组间基础评分量表无显著差异。在 3 个月时间点,真 rTMS 组在不同评分量表上的改善均明显优于假刺激组;此外,1 赫兹组的表现优于 3 赫兹组。最后一次治疗后即刻的皮质兴奋性测量表明,1 赫兹组降低了非病灶半球的兴奋性,增加了病灶半球的兴奋性,而 3 赫兹组仅增加了病灶半球的兴奋性。
这些结果证实,每日五次经颅磁刺激运动皮层,使用非病变半球的 1 赫兹或病变半球的 3 赫兹,可以增强恢复。在 3 个月时,1 赫兹组的改善更为明显。