Chouinard G
University of Montreal, Psychiatric Research Center, Hospital Louis-H Lafontaine, Quebec, Canada.
Acta Psychiatr Scand Suppl. 1990;358:111-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1990.tb05301.x.
We carried out a four-week double-blind placebo-controlled study comparing remoxipride (n = 20) to chlorpromazine (n = 21) and placebo (n = 21) in the treatment of newly admitted schizophrenic patients with acute exacerbation. Chlorpromazine was found to be significantly better than remoxipride on the dropout rate due to inefficacy, Clinical Global Impression (CGI) of severity of illness and Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale (BPRS). Chlorpromazine tended to be better than placebo on the dropout rate related to inefficacy, Nurse's Global Impression (NGI) of severity and on the BPRS measures of positive symptoms (hallucinatory behaviour and thinking disturbance factor). We were unable to detect a difference between remoxipride and placebo except that remoxipride was better in patients who had previously responded well to neuroleptics. Both drugs induced significantly more parkinsonism than placebo, but differently so: chlorpromazine induced both types of parkinsonism hypo- and hyper-kinetic symptoms, whereas remoxipride induced hyperkinetic symptoms. Chlorpromazine caused more tachycardia, drowsiness, orthostatic dizziness, and dry mouth than the other two treatments, while patients on remoxipride suffered more from insomnia than those on the other two treatments.
我们进行了一项为期四周的双盲安慰剂对照研究,比较瑞莫必利(n = 20)、氯丙嗪(n = 21)和安慰剂(n = 21)对新入院的急性加重期精神分裂症患者的治疗效果。结果发现,在因疗效不佳导致的脱落率、临床总体印象量表(CGI)评定的疾病严重程度以及简明精神病评定量表(BPRS)方面,氯丙嗪显著优于瑞莫必利。在因疗效不佳导致的脱落率、护士总体印象量表(NGI)评定的严重程度以及BPRS评定的阳性症状(幻觉行为和思维障碍因子)方面,氯丙嗪也倾向于优于安慰剂。除了既往对抗精神病药物反应良好的患者中瑞莫必利表现更好外,我们未能检测到瑞莫必利与安慰剂之间存在差异。两种药物诱发的帕金森症均显著多于安慰剂,但方式不同:氯丙嗪诱发了低动力和高动力两种类型的帕金森症状,而瑞莫必利仅诱发高动力症状。氯丙嗪引起的心动过速、嗜睡、体位性头晕和口干比其他两种治疗更多,而服用瑞莫必利的患者比服用其他两种治疗的患者更多地出现失眠。