Human Performance Laboratory, Department of Health and Exercise Science, University of Oklahoma, Norman, Oklahoma, USA.
J Strength Cond Res. 2010 Aug;24(8):2227-38. doi: 10.1519/JSC.0b013e3181aeb0cf.
Energy drink use has grown despite limited research to support efficacy or safety and amid concerns when combined with exercise. The purpose of this study was to assess the effects of 10 weeks of once-daily energy drink consumption or energy drink consumption with exercise on measures of body composition, cardiorespiratory fitness, strength, mood, and safety in previously sedentary males. Thirty-eight males were randomly assigned to energy drink + exercise (EX-A), energy drink (NEX-A), placebo + exercise (EX-B), or placebo (NEX-B). All participants consumed 1 drink per day for 10 weeks; EX-A and EX-B participated in 10 weeks of resistance and endurance exercise. Testing was performed before (PRE) and after (POST) the 10-week intervention. No significant (p > 0.05) changes were observed for body composition, fitness, or strength in NEX-A; however, significantly greater decreases in fat mass and percentage body fat and increases in VO2peak were observed in EX-A versus EX-B. Ventilatory threshold (VT), minute ventilation, VO2 at VT, and power output at VT improved significantly PRE to POST in EX-A but not in EX-B or nonexercising groups. Clinical markers for hepatic, renal, cardiovascular, and immune function, as determined by PRE and POST blood work revealed no adverse effects in response to the energy drink. Mood was not affected by energy drink use. Absent energy restriction or other dietary controls, chronic ingestion of a once-daily low-calorie energy drink appears ineffective at improving body composition, cardiorespiratory fitness, or strength in sedentary males. However, when combined with exercise, preworkout energy drink consumption may significantly improve some physiological adaptations to combined aerobic and resistance training.
尽管有限的研究支持能量饮料的功效或安全性,并且担心与运动结合时会产生影响,但能量饮料的使用仍在增加。本研究的目的是评估每日一次能量饮料消费或与运动相结合的能量饮料消费对以前久坐的男性的身体成分、心肺健康、力量、情绪和安全性的影响。38 名男性被随机分配到能量饮料+运动(EX-A)、能量饮料(NEX-A)、安慰剂+运动(EX-B)或安慰剂(NEX-B)组。所有参与者在 10 周内每天饮用 1 份饮料;EX-A 和 EX-B 参加了 10 周的阻力和耐力运动。测试在 10 周干预前(PRE)和后(POST)进行。NEX-A 的身体成分、健康状况或力量没有显著变化(p>0.05);然而,与 EX-B 相比,EX-A 中脂肪量和体脂百分比的显著降低以及 VO2peak 的增加更为明显。通气阈(VT)、分钟通气量、VT 时的 VO2 和 VT 时的功率输出在 EX-A 中从 PRE 到 POST 均显著提高,但在 EX-B 或不运动组中则没有。通过 PRE 和 POST 血液检查确定的肝、肾、心血管和免疫功能的临床标志物未显示出对能量饮料的不良反应。能量饮料的使用未影响情绪。在没有能量限制或其他饮食控制的情况下,慢性摄入每日一次的低卡路里能量饮料似乎不能改善久坐男性的身体成分、心肺健康或力量。然而,当与运动结合使用时,运动前饮用能量饮料可能会显著改善有氧运动和抗阻训练相结合的一些生理适应。