Mahaffey K R, Fowler B A
Environ Health Perspect. 1977 Aug;19:165-71. doi: 10.1289/ehp.7719165.
Humans are exposed to a number of toxic elements in the environment; however, most experiments with laboratory animals investigate only one toxic element. To determine if concomitant exposure to lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), and/or arsenic (As) modified the changes produced by any one metal in various parameters of toxicity, 168 male, Sprague-Dawley, young adult rats were fed nutritionally adequate diets to which had been added 0 or 200 ppm Pb as Pb acetate, or 50 ppm Cd as Cd chloride, or 50 ppm As as sodium arsenate or arsanilic acid in a factorial design for a period of 10 weeks. At these concentrations, Cd and As reduced weight gain even when differences in food intake were taken into account; administration of both Cd and As depressed weight gain more than did either metal alone. Pb did not adversely affect food consumption or weight gain. Increased numbers of red blood cells (RBCs) were observed following administration of Pb, Cd, or As; usually more cells were observed when two or three metals were administered, compared to individual metals. Despite increasing numbers of circulating RBCs, hemoglobin and hematocrit were reduced, especially with the Pb-Cd combination and the Cd-arsanilic acid combination. Specific effects of Pb on heme synthesis were observed, including increased urinary excretion of delta-aminolevulinic acid; this increase was reduced by the presence of dietary cadmium. Analyses of blood showed values for the laboratory rat within normal ranges for blood urea nitrogen, creatinine, cholesterol, calcium, albumin, total protein, and bilirubin. Uric acid was increased by Pb, with little modification by dietary Cd or As content. Serum glutamate-oxalate transaminase activity was reduced by As. Serum alkaline phosphatase was greatly reduced by either As or Cd but not Pb. Combinations of As and Cd did not further reduce the activity of this enzyme. Kidney weight and kidney weight/body weight ratios were increased by Pb alone, with no effects of Cd or As alone or as interactions. Liver weight/body weight ratios were reduced in animals fed 50 ppm dietary Cd. Kidney histology shows predominantly Pb effects, namely, intranuclear inclusion bodies and cloudy swelling. Ultrastructural evaluation of kidneys from Pb-treated animals disclosed nuclear inclusion bodies of the usual morphology and mitochondrial swelling. Concurrent administration of Cd greatly minimized Pb effects on the kidney under conditions of this experiment. Liver histology suggests an increased rate of cell turnover with either As compound, but few specific changes.
人类在环境中会接触到多种有毒元素;然而,大多数用实验动物进行的实验仅研究一种有毒元素。为了确定同时接触铅(Pb)、镉(Cd)和/或砷(As)是否会改变任何一种金属在各种毒性参数中所产生的变化,将168只雄性斯普拉格 - 道利成年幼鼠按照析因设计喂食营养充足的日粮,日粮中添加了0或200 ppm的醋酸铅形式的Pb、或50 ppm的氯化镉形式的Cd、或50 ppm的砷酸钠或对氨基苯胂酸形式的As,持续10周。在这些浓度下,即使考虑到食物摄入量的差异,Cd和As也会降低体重增加;同时给予Cd和As比单独给予任何一种金属更能抑制体重增加。Pb对食物消耗或体重增加没有不利影响。给予Pb、Cd或As后观察到红细胞(RBC)数量增加;通常与单独给予一种金属相比,同时给予两种或三种金属时观察到的细胞更多。尽管循环中的RBC数量增加,但血红蛋白和血细胞比容降低,尤其是在Pb - Cd组合和Cd - 对氨基苯胂酸组合的情况下。观察到Pb对血红素合成有特定影响,包括δ - 氨基乙酰丙酸的尿排泄增加;日粮中镉的存在会减少这种增加。血液分析显示实验大鼠的血尿素氮、肌酐、胆固醇、钙、白蛋白、总蛋白和胆红素的值在正常范围内。尿酸因Pb而增加,日粮中Cd或As含量对其影响不大。血清谷氨酸 - 草酰乙酸转氨酶活性因As而降低。血清碱性磷酸酶因As或Cd而大大降低,但不因Pb而降低。As和Cd的组合并没有进一步降低这种酶的活性。单独的Pb会增加肾脏重量和肾脏重量/体重比,Cd或As单独或相互作用均无影响。喂食50 ppm日粮Cd的动物肝脏重量/体重比降低。肾脏组织学主要显示Pb的影响,即核内包涵体和混浊肿胀。对经Pb处理动物的肾脏进行超微结构评估发现了通常形态的核包涵体和线粒体肿胀。在本实验条件下,同时给予Cd可极大地减轻Pb对肾脏的影响。肝脏组织学表明,使用任何一种As化合物都会使细胞更新率增加,但具体变化很少。