Searleman Alan, Porac Clare, Alvin Jennelle, Peaslee Kendra
Departmetn of Psychology, St. Lawrence University, Canton, NY 13617, USA.
Am J Psychol. 2009 Fall;122(3):383-94.
Previous research has shown that by placing nontargets around the endpoints of the shaft of the Mueller-Lyer illusion it is possible to markedly affect its normal strength. Using the same technique with the Ponzo illusion and the horizontal-vertical illusion, the current study demonstrated a similar ability to affect these other illusions of length. These findings provide varying amounts of support or challenges for different theories of illusion formation. In addition, the results highlight the importance of analyzing illusion data using comparative difference scores and examining separate overestimation and underestimation components in each illusion.
先前的研究表明,通过在穆勒-莱尔错觉(Mueller-Lyer illusion)的线段端点周围放置非目标物,有可能显著影响其正常强度。本研究采用相同技术研究庞佐错觉(Ponzo illusion)和横竖错觉(horizontal-vertical illusion),结果表明该技术也能以类似方式影响这些其他长度错觉。这些发现为不同的错觉形成理论提供了不同程度的支持或挑战。此外,研究结果凸显了使用比较差异分数分析错觉数据以及考察每种错觉中单独的高估和低估成分的重要性。