Townsend Grant, Hughes Toby, Bockmann Michelle, Smith Richard, Brook Alan
Front Oral Biol. 2009;13:136-141. doi: 10.1159/000242406. Epub 2009 Sep 21.
Two metaphors are presented to highlight concepts that could lead to a paradigm shift in dental studies of twins. The first, derived from the Song of Solomon in the Bible, refers to teeth as being twins. This viewpoint emphasises that each tooth should be viewed as a paired structure, not only with its antimere (within the same arch) but also with its isomer (in the opposing arch). The other metaphor provided by Waddington in 1957 is visual and involves 'an epigenetic landscape' that represents the processes of decision-making by cells during development. It likens the different stages of cellular decision-making to a ball rolling down an undulating landscape of interconnecting hills and valleys. This viewpoint helps to explain how distinct differences in dental phenotypes may arise both within and between monozygotic (MZ) co-twins due to relatively minor temporospatial effects during development. Measurements of maximum mesiodistal diameters of teeth in a pair of MZ twins, using calipers and also 2D and 3D imaging systems, have demonstrated that differences in dental crown size occur between antimeric pairs and between corresponding teeth of MZ co-twins. By defining new dental phenotypes that provide more comprehensive descriptions of tooth size and shape, and by drawing on the metaphors described, we are confident of providing new insights into the reasons for observed similarities and differences within, and between, the dentitions of twins. Our approaches will focus on multivariate analyses that take into account the paired arrangement of teeth and also explore epigenetic, as well as genetic and environmental, sources of variation.
本文提出了两个隐喻,以突出那些可能导致双胞胎牙科研究范式转变的概念。第一个隐喻源自《圣经》中的《雅歌》,将牙齿比作双胞胎。这种观点强调,每颗牙齿都应被视为一种成对的结构,不仅与其对侧牙(在同一牙弓内)成对,还与其同名牙(在对侧牙弓中)成对。1957年沃丁顿提出的另一个隐喻是可视化的,涉及“表观遗传景观”,它代表细胞在发育过程中的决策过程。它将细胞决策的不同阶段比作一个球在起伏相连的山丘和山谷的景观中滚动。这种观点有助于解释由于发育过程中相对较小的时空效应,同卵(MZ)双胞胎的同卵双生子内部和之间如何出现明显不同的牙齿表型差异。使用卡尺以及二维和三维成像系统对一对MZ双胞胎的牙齿最大近远中直径进行测量,结果表明,对侧牙对之间以及MZ同卵双生子的相应牙齿之间存在牙冠大小差异。通过定义能够更全面描述牙齿大小和形状的新牙齿表型,并借鉴上述隐喻,我们有信心为观察到的双胞胎牙列内部和之间的异同原因提供新的见解。我们的方法将侧重于多变量分析,这种分析考虑到牙齿的成对排列,同时探索表观遗传以及遗传和环境方面的变异来源。