Social Medicine, University of Bristol, Canynge Hall, Bristol BS8 2PR, UK.
Addiction. 2009 Nov;104(11):1856-61. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2009.02736.x.
We consider how many cannabis users may need to be prevented in order to prevent one case of schizophrenia or psychosis [defined as number needed to prevent (NNP)].
Calculation for England and Wales using best available estimates of: incidence of schizophrenia; rates of heavy and light cannabis use; and risk that cannabis causes schizophrenia.
In men the annual mean NNP for heavy cannabis and schizophrenia ranged from 2800 [90% confidence interval (CI) 2018-4530] in those aged 20-24 years to 4700 (90% CI 3114-8416) in those aged 35-39. In women, mean NNP for heavy cannabis use and schizophrenia ranged from 5470 (90% CI 3640-9839) in those aged 25-29 to 10 870 (90% CI 6786-22 732) in 35-39-year-olds. Equivalent mean NNP for heavy cannabis use and psychosis were lower, from 1360 (90% CI 1007-2124) in men aged 20-24 and 2480 (90% CI 1408-3518) in women aged 16-19. The mean and median number of light cannabis users that would need to be prevented in order to prevent one case of schizophrenia or psychosis per year are four to five times greater than among heavy users.
The number of young people who need to be exposed to an intervention to generate NNP and prevent one case of schizophrenia will be even larger. The public health importance of preventing cannabis to reduce schizophrenia or psychosis remains uncertain. More attention should be given to testing the hypothesis that cannabis is related causally to psychotic outcomes, and to considering what strategies will be the most effective in reducing heavy cannabis use among young people.
我们考虑需要预防多少大麻使用者,以防止出现一例精神分裂症或精神病[定义为需要预防的人数(NNP)]。
使用最佳可用估计值,针对英格兰和威尔士进行计算:精神分裂症的发病率;重度和轻度大麻使用的比率;以及大麻导致精神分裂症的风险。
在男性中,20-24 岁年龄组重度大麻和精神分裂症的年平均 NNP 范围为 2800(90%置信区间(CI)2018-4530),35-39 岁年龄组为 4700(90% CI 3114-8416)。在女性中,25-29 岁年龄组重度大麻使用和精神分裂症的平均 NNP 范围为 5470(90% CI 3640-9839),35-39 岁年龄组为 10870(90% CI 6786-22732)。重度大麻使用和精神病的等效平均 NNP 较低,20-24 岁男性为 1360(90% CI 1007-2124),16-19 岁女性为 2480(90% CI 1408-3518)。为了预防每年一例精神分裂症或精神病,需要预防四到五个轻度大麻使用者。
需要接触干预措施以产生 NNP 并预防一例精神分裂症的年轻人数量将会更大。预防大麻以减少精神分裂症或精神病的公共卫生重要性仍不确定。应该更加关注测试大麻与精神病结果之间存在因果关系的假设,并考虑哪些策略在减少年轻人重度大麻使用方面最有效。