Forni J, Miles K, Hamill M
Barnet and Chase Farm NHS Trust, Chase Farm Hospital, The Ridgeway, Enfield EN2 8JL, UK.
Int J STD AIDS. 2009 Nov;20(11):797-8. doi: 10.1258/ijsa.2009.009186. Epub 2009 Oct 15.
This audit aimed to determine the usefulness of microscopy to detect presumptive rectal gonorrhoea (GC) infection in asymptomatic men. We retrospectively audited more than 400 male patients attending a London genitourinary medicine clinic from January 2005 to March 2007 who tested rectal culture positive for Neisseria gonorrhoeae and compared this with the microscopy detection rate. In total, 123/423 (29%) of culture positive samples were microscopy positive. Of those that tested microscopy negative (300/423), 64 (21%) were symptomatic and 236 (79%) asymptomatic. In addition, a time and motion study examined 81 rectal slides over a two-week period to identify microscopy reading time required to make a presumptive diagnosis of GC. Three slides were positive, resulting in six hours and 45 minutes to detect one positive sample. Given the low sensitivity for rectal microscopy coupled with the length of time required to obtain a presumptive positive rectal GC result, we believe rectal microscopy is no longer a cost-effective tool screening for asymptomatic men, and this report supports the BASHH guideline that it is not recommended in the management of asymptomatic rectal infection.
本次审计旨在确定显微镜检查在检测无症状男性直肠淋病(GC)感染方面的实用性。我们回顾性审计了2005年1月至2007年3月期间在伦敦一家性传播疾病诊所就诊的400多名男性患者,这些患者的直肠培养淋病奈瑟菌呈阳性,并将其与显微镜检测率进行了比较。总体而言,423份培养阳性样本中有123份(29%)显微镜检查呈阳性。在显微镜检查呈阴性的样本中(423份中的300份),64份(21%)有症状,236份(79%)无症状。此外,一项时间与动作研究在两周内检查了81张直肠涂片,以确定做出GC初步诊断所需的显微镜检查读取时间。有3张涂片呈阳性,检测出1个阳性样本需要6小时45分钟。鉴于直肠显微镜检查的敏感性较低,加上获得直肠GC初步阳性结果所需的时间较长,我们认为直肠显微镜检查不再是筛查无症状男性的具有成本效益的工具,本报告支持英国性健康与艾滋病协会(BASHH)的指南,即在无症状直肠感染的管理中不推荐使用。