Mulvey Edward P, Schubert Carol A, Chung He Len
Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, USA.
Child Youth Serv Rev. 2007 Apr 1;29(4):518-544. doi: 10.1016/j.childyouth.2006.10.006.
The juvenile justice system faces a difficult challenge when providing services to serious adolescent offenders, having to balance community safety concerns with hopes for successful intervention. Increasing the effectiveness of this system rests partially on having a clearer picture of the regularities of current service provision to these adolescents. This study describes the types of services received by a large (N=868) sample of adjudicated serious offenders from two metropolitan areas over a two-year follow-up period after adjudication in court, and examines whether indicators of need for services determine the types of services received in the juvenile justice system. Findings indicate that: 1) the level of specialized services received is rather low, 2) there is considerable site variability, 3) the service needs of adolescents sent to different types of settings appear to be generally equivalent, 4) state training schools appear to provide about the same level of services found in contracted provider settings, and 5) need is an inconsistent determinant of service provision.
少年司法系统在为严重青少年罪犯提供服务时面临着一项艰巨挑战,即必须在社区安全问题与成功干预的期望之间取得平衡。提高该系统的有效性部分取决于更清楚地了解当前为这些青少年提供服务的规律。本研究描述了来自两个大都市地区的大量(N = 868)被判定为严重罪犯的样本在法庭判决后的两年随访期内所接受的服务类型,并研究了服务需求指标是否决定了少年司法系统中所接受的服务类型。研究结果表明:1)所接受的专业服务水平相当低,2)存在相当大的场所差异,3)被送往不同类型场所的青少年的服务需求似乎总体相当,4)州立培训学校提供的服务水平似乎与签约服务提供商场所的服务水平相当,5)需求是服务提供的一个不一致的决定因素。