RMIT University, Australia.
Med Teach. 2009 Nov;31(11):994-1000. doi: 10.3109/01421590802572726.
Undergraduate students of the twenty-first century are widely regarded as 'technologically savvy' and have embraced the electronic information world. The literature, however, describes undergraduate students as using a limited range of electronic information sources and not critically evaluating the information they retrieve from internet searches.
The aim was to evaluate a purposefully designed intervention that sought to expand the information search and evaluation practices of undergraduate students. The intervention scaffolded an independent learning activity in the form of a group-based project.
Survey methodology was used to collect data from student pre- and post-intervention for two cohorts of students who undertook the intervention in 2005 and 2006 involving a total of 71 students. Percentages were used to describe survey findings and chi-square analysis and Fisher's exact test examined differences between groups.
Questionnaires were completed by 59 students (response rate 83%) pre-intervention and 49 students (response rate 69%) post-intervention. Post-intervention there were positive and statistically significant differences in database searching behaviour (p = 0.000), use of Google Scholar (p = 0.035) and number of criteria used to evaluate information retrieved from the internet (p = 0.000) by students.
By positively reshaping the electronic information search and evaluation practices of students we are helping students to find informed information sources as they engage in independent learning activities at university and as future health professionals.
二十一世纪的本科生被广泛认为是“精通技术”的,并且已经融入了电子信息世界。然而,文献描述本科生只使用了有限的电子信息资源,并且没有对他们从互联网搜索中检索到的信息进行批判性评估。
本研究旨在评估一项旨在扩大本科生信息搜索和评估实践的有针对性的干预措施。该干预措施以小组为基础的项目形式为独立学习活动提供了支持。
采用调查方法,对 2005 年和 2006 年接受干预的两批学生进行了学生干预前后的调查,共有 71 名学生参与。使用百分比来描述调查结果,卡方检验和 Fisher 确切检验检验组间差异。
干预前有 59 名学生(回应率 83%)完成了问卷,干预后有 49 名学生(回应率 69%)完成了问卷。干预后,学生在数据库搜索行为(p = 0.000)、Google Scholar 的使用(p = 0.035)和从互联网检索到的信息评估标准的数量(p = 0.000)方面均有积极的、统计学上显著的差异。
通过积极重塑学生的电子信息搜索和评估实践,我们帮助学生在大学进行独立学习活动时以及作为未来的医疗保健专业人员找到有见地的信息来源。