Laboratory of Biostatistics, Department of Nursing, School of Health Sciences, University of Athens, Papadiamantopoulou 123, Athens 11527, Greece.
Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2010 Feb;119(3):621-31. doi: 10.1007/s10549-009-0630-8.
In the metastatic setting, a detected time trend to improved prognosis could be attributed to the corresponding recent advances in the therapeutic approaches. The aim of the current study was to first assess, in a large cohort of well over a thousand patients, the time trends in survival in MBC for the last 15 years and second to explore its association to prognostic factors affecting outcome including therapeutic regimen. This meta-analysis uses individual patient data collected from all the trials on MBC (6 nonrandomized, 4 randomized) conducted by HeCOG from 1991 through 2006. Four 4-year time periods (1991-1994, 1995-1998, 1999-2002, and 2003-2006) were constructed for exploration of time trends in survival according to the patient's date of metastatic diagnosis. Different first line regimens in the 10 trials include anthracycline monotherapy (epirubicin, in the early 1990s) and taxane containing regimens either as monotherapy or in different combinations with anthracyclines or other drugs. In two phase II studies and in the last randomized study, trastuzumab was administered in all the patients with HER2 overexpressing tumors. In this study, information is based on a total of 1361 patients with a median follow up of 3.7 years and median survival of 1.9 years (median survival 1.28, 1.68, 2.20, and 2.57 years for 1991-1994, 1995-1998, 1999-2002, and 2003-2006, respectively). Survival improved significantly across diagnosis time periods, by 25, 44, and 51%, respectively, in each time period (1995-1998: HR = 0.75, P = 0.004; 1999-2002: HR = 0.56, P\0.001; 2003-2006: HR = 0.49, P\0.001) as compared to the first time period (1991-1994). The effect of metastatic diagnosis time period remains almost unchanged in the presence of the following significant prognostic factors: performance status, hormonal receptor status, previous adjuvant chemotherapy, previous adjuvant hormonal treatment, visceral metastasis at entry, and number of metastatic sites. When exploring the effect of new systemic treatment introduction, taking into account the same significant prognostic factors, the effect of diagnosis time period disappears, and the survival improvement is explained directly by the introduction of new agents (hormonal treatment for metastatic disease: yes vs. no: HR = 0.72, P\0.001; taxanes at first line: yes vs. no: HR = 0.69, P = 0.002; trastuzumab at first line: yes vs. no: HR = 0.63, P\0.001). The results of this study provide significant evidence of improvement in prognosis of MBC patients within the last 15 years, taking into account all the important significant prognostic factors, and this improvement can be attributed to the use of new systemic treatment agents in the management of the disease.
在转移性疾病的背景下,生存预后改善的时间趋势可能归因于治疗方法的相应近期进展。本研究的目的首先是在过去 15 年中,在超过 1000 名患者的大样本中评估 MBC 患者的生存时间趋势,其次是探索其与影响预后的预后因素的关联,包括治疗方案。本荟萃分析使用了 HeCOG 从 1991 年至 2006 年进行的所有转移性乳腺癌(6 项非随机、4 项随机)试验中收集的个体患者数据。根据患者转移性诊断日期,构建了 4 个 4 年时间区间(1991-1994 年、1995-1998 年、1999-2002 年和 2003-2006 年),以探索生存时间趋势。在 10 项试验中,不同的一线方案包括蒽环类药物单药治疗(表柔比星,90 年代早期)和紫杉烷类药物单药治疗或与蒽环类药物或其他药物联合使用的方案。在两项 II 期研究和最后一项随机研究中,曲妥珠单抗在所有 HER2 过表达肿瘤患者中使用。在这项研究中,信息基于总共 1361 名患者,中位随访 3.7 年,中位生存期为 1.9 年(1991-1994 年、1995-1998 年、1999-2002 年和 2003-2006 年的中位生存期分别为 1.28、1.68、2.20 和 2.57 年)。在每个时间段,生存都有显著改善,分别为 25%、44%和 51%(1995-1998 年:HR=0.75,P=0.004;1999-2002 年:HR=0.56,P\0.001;2003-2006 年:HR=0.49,P\0.001),与第一个时间段(1991-1994 年)相比。在存在以下显著预后因素的情况下,转移性诊断时间的影响几乎保持不变:表现状态、激素受体状态、辅助化疗前、辅助激素治疗前、初诊时的内脏转移和转移部位数量。在探索新的全身治疗方法的引入效果时,考虑到相同的显著预后因素,诊断时间的影响消失,生存的改善直接由新药物的引入解释(转移性疾病的激素治疗:是 vs. 否:HR=0.72,P\0.001;一线使用紫杉烷类药物:是 vs. 否:HR=0.69,P=0.002;一线使用曲妥珠单抗:是 vs. 否:HR=0.63,P\0.001)。这项研究的结果提供了过去 15 年内转移性乳腺癌患者预后改善的重要证据,考虑到所有重要的显著预后因素,这种改善可以归因于疾病管理中新的全身治疗药物的使用。