Qin Xing Jun, Kong Jun, Lu Li, Lu Zhen Fu, Wang Xu Kai
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, China Medical University College of Stomatology, Shenyang, People's Republic of China.
J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2010 Apr;68(4):739-43. doi: 10.1016/j.joms.2009.04.002.
To determine the feasibility of implementing problem-based learning (PBL) in a large class and whether previous PBL experience is necessary.
A total of 236 students from 2 large classes at China Medical University were enrolled. One class (118 students) had had a previous small-group PBL experience and another class (113 students) had not. Each class was subdivided into 15 groups (7 to 8 students/group) and took 2 separate 100-minute PBL sessions per week with the same teaching faculty. Each PBL class had 2 facilitators, 1 content expert facilitator, and 1 nonexpert facilitator. The results of the theoretical examination and case analysis examinations were analyzed using the t test. Questionnaires were used to evaluate both student and facilitator perceptions.
The feedback from both students and facilitators was positive. According to the questionnaires, both experienced and non-experienced students acknowledged that the teaching method was enjoyable and functional. The test results showed students had achieved the learning objectives. The results of the theoretical and case analysis examinations showed no significant difference between the PBL experienced class and the non-experienced class. The mean study hours spent weekly by the students after class on the course were about 6.3 +/- 1.1 hours for the non-experienced students and 4.7 +/- 0.981 hours for the experienced students (t = 11.94, P < .001). The non-experienced students showed more preference for the content expert tutor.
Implementing PBL in a large class is feasible without extracting great demand on limited educational resources. Previous PBL experience is helpful but not necessary.
确定在大班中实施基于问题的学习(PBL)的可行性以及先前的PBL经验是否必要。
招募了中国医科大学两个大班的共236名学生。一个班级(118名学生)有过小组PBL经验,另一个班级(113名学生)没有。每个班级再细分为15个小组(每组7至8名学生),每周由相同的教师进行2次单独的100分钟PBL课程。每个PBL班级有2名引导教师,1名内容专家引导教师和1名非专家引导教师。使用t检验分析理论考试和案例分析考试的结果。通过问卷调查来评估学生和引导教师的看法。
学生和引导教师的反馈都是积极的。根据问卷调查,有经验和无经验的学生都承认这种教学方法有趣且实用。测试结果表明学生达到了学习目标。理论考试和案例分析考试的结果显示,有PBL经验的班级和无经验的班级之间没有显著差异。课后学生每周在该课程上花费的平均学习时间,无经验的学生约为6.3±1.1小时,有经验的学生为4.7±0.981小时(t = 11.94,P <.001)。无经验的学生对内容专家导师表现出更多的偏好。
在大班中实施PBL是可行的,对有限的教育资源没有很大需求。先前的PBL经验有帮助但不是必需的。