Kira Jun-ichi
Department of Neurology, Neurological Institute, Graduate School of Medical Sciences, Kyushu University.
Rinsho Shinkeigaku. 2009 Sep;49(9):549-59. doi: 10.5692/clinicalneurol.49.549.
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is rare in Asians, but selective and severe involvement of the optic nerve and spinal cord is characteristic when it does occur. Recent epidemiological studies have demonstrated an increase in the prevalence of MS in Japan. Moreover, while there are two distinct phenotypes of MS in Asians, opticospinal (OSMS) and conventional (CMS), it is important to determine if MS phenotypes in Japanese are presently undergoing change. Four nationwide surveys of MS have been conducted in Japan: 1972, 1982, 1989, and 2004. The most recent survey demonstrated: (1) a four-fold increase in the estimated number of clinically definite MS patients in 2003 (9.900; crude MS prevalence. 7.7/100.000) compared to the numbers in 1972; (2) a shift in the peak age at onset from the early 30s in 1989 to the early 20s in 2003; (3) a successive proportional decrease in optic-spinal involvement; (4) a significant north-south gradient for the CMS/OSMS ratio: (5) after dividing the mainland (30-45 degrees North) into northern and southern parts at 37 degrees N, northern-born northern-residents (northern patients) showed a significantly higher CMS/OSMS ratio and higher frequency of brain lesions fulfilling the Barkhof criteria (Barkhof brain lesions) than southern-born southern-residents; (6) among northern patients, the absolute numbers of CMS patients and those with Barkhof brain lesions rapidly increased with advancing birth year; (7) further classifications based on MRI findings demonstrated distinct demographic features with not only the CMS/OSMS phenotype but also the presence or absence of longitudinally extensive spinal cord lesions (LESCLs). In northern patients, the incidence of OSMS with LESCLs had decreased with advancing year of birth, while incidences of intermediate phenotypes, such as CMS with LESCLs and OSMS without LESCLs, had increased. Although phenotypic changes appeared to be mostly attributable to the increase in CMS patients with Barkhof brain lesions in younger northern populations, the emergence of such intermediate phenotypes may support the notion that CMS and OSMS represent opposite ends of a single spectrum of disease. These findings suggest that phenotype is drastically altered by environmental factors, such as latitude and "Westernization". The recent discovery of a specific IgG against neuromyelitis optica (NMO) suggests that NMO is a disease entity distinct from MS. NMO-IgG targeting aquaporin-4 (AQP4) is present in 30 to 60% of Japanese OSMS patients with LESCLs. MS patients with anti-AQP4 antibodies were not responsive to interferon beta-1b while those without anti-AQP4 antibody did respond. In CSF, IL-17, IFN-gamma, granulocyte-colony stimulating factor, and IL-8 were markedly upregulated in OSMS patients, irrespective of the presence or absence of the anti-AQP4 antibody. Pathological studies of autopsy specimens of OSMS patients disclose that there are two subtypes of OSMS, with or without showing a selective AQP4 loss; although both subtypes had severe necrotic spinal cord lesions. There are also OSMS cases showing both pathological patterns at different lesions. These findings indicate that both anti-AQP4 autoimmunity-related and -unrelated OSMS occur in Japanese. Th17/Th1 cells are involved in both conditions, while additional humoral factors also act in the former.
多发性硬化症(MS)在亚洲人中较为罕见,但一旦发病,其特征是视神经和脊髓会出现选择性且严重的受累情况。最近的流行病学研究表明,日本MS的患病率有所上升。此外,亚洲人MS有两种不同的表型,即视神经脊髓型(OSMS)和传统型(CMS),因此确定日本MS的表型目前是否正在发生变化很重要。日本已进行了四次全国性的MS调查:1972年、1982年、1989年和2004年。最近的调查显示:(1)与1972年相比,2003年临床确诊的MS患者估计数量增加了四倍(9900例;粗MS患病率为7.7/100000);(2)发病高峰年龄从1989年的30岁出头转移到了2003年的20岁出头;(3)视神经脊髓受累比例持续下降;(4)CMS/OSMS比值存在显著的南北梯度差异;(5)将日本本土(北纬30 - 45度)在北纬37度处分为北部和南部后,出生在北方且居住在北方的居民(北方患者)的CMS/OSMS比值显著高于出生在南方且居住在南方的居民,并且符合Barkhof标准的脑病变(Barkhof脑病变)频率更高;(6)在北方患者中,CMS患者和有Barkhof脑病变患者的绝对数量随着出生年份的增加而迅速上升;(7)基于MRI结果的进一步分类显示,不仅CMS/OSMS表型,而且有无纵向广泛脊髓病变(LESCLs)都具有明显的人口统计学特征。在北方患者中,伴有LESCLs的OSMS发病率随出生年份的增加而下降,而中间表型的发病率,如伴有LESCLs的CMS和不伴有LESCLs的OSMS,则有所上升。尽管表型变化似乎主要归因于北方年轻人群中伴有Barkhof脑病变的CMS患者数量的增加,但这些中间表型的出现可能支持CMS和OSMS代表单一疾病谱两端的观点。这些发现表明,表型会因纬度和“西方化”等环境因素而发生显著改变。最近发现了一种针对视神经脊髓炎(NMO)的特异性IgG,这表明NMO是一种与MS不同的疾病实体。靶向水通道蛋白4(AQP4)的NMO - IgG存在于30%至60%伴有LESCLs的日本OSMS患者中。有抗AQP4抗体的MS患者对干扰素β - 1b无反应,而无抗AQP4抗体的患者则有反应。在脑脊液中,无论有无抗AQP4抗体,OSMS患者的IL - 17、IFN - γ、粒细胞集落刺激因子和IL - 8均显著上调。对OSMS患者尸检标本的病理研究表明,OSMS有两种亚型,一种有选择性AQP4缺失,另一种没有;尽管两种亚型都有严重的坏死性脊髓病变。也有OSMS病例在不同病变处表现出两种病理模式。这些发现表明,在日本,与抗AQP4自身免疫相关和不相关的OSMS均有发生。Th17/Th1细胞在两种情况下均有参与,而在前一种情况下还有其他体液因子起作用。