Department of Sociology, Hofstra University, Hempstead, New York 11549, USA.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2010 Jan;11(1):18-26. doi: 10.1177/1524838009349516. Epub 2009 Nov 19.
In this article, the sociological and historical approaches and literatures are synthesized to present the historical background of the treatment that child-abusing and child-killing parents are receiving in the legal system today. The roots of the formation of contemporary institutional responses to severe child abuse and child homicide are traced and latest developments are examined critically. Durkheim's insights regarding the functions of law are highlighted by pointing out how, throughout history, crimes against children become stand-ins for larger societal problem. The latest innovations in the criminal branch of child protection consist of the specialized prosecution bureaus and court parts dealing with physical and sexual violence against children. Integral to the new developments in child protection are ''multidisciplinary,'' comprehensive approaches to the processing of criminal cases, involving teams consisting of representatives from the police, the prosecution, public and private social work and child protection agencies, and psychiatric, pediatric, and other medical practitioners and community partners. These developments exemplify heightened focus on criminal prosecution of parental crimes against children, inevitably leading to questions and policy concerns regarding resources geared toward punishment rather than prevention.
本文综合运用社会学和历史学的方法和文献,呈现了当今法律体系对待虐待和杀害儿童的父母的历史背景。追溯了当代对严重虐待和杀害儿童的制度反应形成的根源,并批判性地审视了最新的发展。通过指出犯罪如何在历史上成为更大的社会问题的代表,突出了迪尔凯姆关于法律功能的观点。儿童保护刑事部门的最新创新包括专门的起诉局和处理针对儿童的身体和性暴力的法庭部分。儿童保护的新发展的重要组成部分是涉及警察、起诉方、公共和私人社会工作以及儿童保护机构以及精神科、儿科和其他医学从业者和社区合作伙伴的代表的团队的“多学科”综合方法来处理刑事案件。这些发展体现了对父母犯罪的刑事起诉的高度关注,不可避免地导致了关于针对惩罚而不是预防的资源的问题和政策关注。