Jaiswal Alok K, Paudel Keshab R, Shrestha Situ L, Jaiswal Sunita
College of Dental Surgery, UCMS, Bhairahawa, Nepal.
J Orthod. 2009 Dec;36(4):253-9. doi: 10.1179/14653120723283.
To test the use of Moyers prediction method and Tanaka and Johnston's equations for use in a Nepalese population and to construct new probability tables and prediction formulae based on the actual tooth sizes in a sample of the Nepalese population.
Cross-sectional. SOURCE AND SETTING: Dental, medical and nursing science students at the B.P. Koirala Institute of Health Sciences, Dharan, Nepal.
The sample consisted of 100 Nepalese males and 100 females aged between 17 and 23 years. Subjects without any previous orthodontic treatment, fully erupted permanent teeth and with no dental anomalies were recruited. Dental study models were taken and measurements of the mesio-distal widths of teeth were carried out using digital caliper. The measured values were compared with predicted values derived from Moyers method and Tanaka and Johnston equations. Independent t tests were used to examine differences between genders. Correlation coefficients and linear regression equations were used to compare the actual Nepalese tooth widths with predicted values
Moyers method at 50% tends to underestimate the actual width of the canine and premolars in males by 0.3 mm and overestimate the width in females by 0.2 mm. The Tanaka and Johnston method tends to overestimate the actual width of the canine and premolars in both males (0.7 mm) and females 1.0 mm.
The newly developed regression equations are more accurate for prediction of width of unerupted permanent teeth in a Nepalese population. Further studies are required based on larger sample size, to confirm the applicability of the new regression equations proposed.
测试莫耶斯预测法以及田中与约翰斯顿公式在尼泊尔人群中的应用,并根据尼泊尔人群样本的实际牙尺寸构建新的概率表和预测公式。
横断面研究。
尼泊尔达兰的B.P. 柯伊拉腊健康科学研究所的牙科、医学及护理学专业学生。
样本包括100名年龄在17至23岁之间的尼泊尔男性和100名女性。招募未曾接受过正畸治疗、恒牙完全萌出且无牙齿异常的受试者。制取牙科研究模型,使用数字卡尺测量牙齿的近远中宽度。将测量值与通过莫耶斯法以及田中与约翰斯顿公式得出的预测值进行比较。采用独立t检验来检验性别差异。使用相关系数和线性回归方程将尼泊尔人的实际牙宽度与预测值进行比较。
莫耶斯法在50%时往往会低估男性犬齿和前磨牙的实际宽度0.3毫米,而高估女性的宽度0.2毫米。田中与约翰斯顿法往往会高估男性(0.7毫米)和女性(1.0毫米)犬齿和前磨牙的实际宽度。
新开发的回归方程在预测尼泊尔人群中未萌出恒牙的宽度方面更为准确。需要基于更大样本量进行进一步研究,以确认所提出的新回归方程的适用性。