Straub W H, Gur D, Good W F, Campbell W L, Davis P L, Hecht S T, Skolnick M L, Thaete F L, Rosenthal M S, Sashin D
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, University of Pittsburgh, PA 15261.
Radiology. 1991 Mar;178(3):739-43. doi: 10.1148/radiology.178.3.1994411.
Whether the display medium--film versus cathode ray tube (CRT)--affects observer performance during interpretation of computed tomographic (CT) images is an important research issue in these times of implementation and growth of picture archiving and communications systems in radiology. The authors performed a multiobserver receiver operating characteristic (ROC) study to determine the performance of radiologists who read abdominal CT studies displayed on film, as well as on a high-resolution workstation (video monitor) that made use of three different display modes. A total of 166 examinations were evaluated by eight radiologists, who recorded their ordinal confidence ratings of the demonstration of presence or absence of abdominal masses. ROC analysis showed small differences in the confidence ratings assigned by individual readers for the detection and interpretation tasks. Results for the group as a whole showed no significant reduction or improvement in observer performance when ratings for any one of the workstation display modes were analyzed. The results of this study demonstrate that current CRT display technology is adequate for enabling the primary detection of abdominal masses with CT examinations.
在放射学中图片存档与通信系统不断实施和发展的当下,显示介质(胶片与阴极射线管[CRT])在计算机断层扫描(CT)图像解读过程中是否会影响观察者的表现是一个重要的研究问题。作者进行了一项多观察者接受操作特性(ROC)研究,以确定阅读腹部CT研究的放射科医生在解读显示在胶片上以及利用三种不同显示模式的高分辨率工作站(视频监视器)上的图像时的表现。八位放射科医生对总共166例检查进行了评估,他们记录了对腹部肿块有无显示的序贯置信度评级。ROC分析显示,个体读者在检测和解读任务中给出的置信度评级存在微小差异。对整个组的结果分析表明,当分析任何一种工作站显示模式的评级时,观察者的表现没有显著降低或提高。这项研究的结果表明,当前的CRT显示技术足以在CT检查中实现对腹部肿块的初步检测。