Kokesh J, Kazmers A, Zierler R E
Department of Surgery, Seattle Veterans Administration Medical Center, Washington.
Ann Vasc Surg. 1991 Jan;5(1):66-70. doi: 10.1007/BF02021781.
To assess the clinical effectiveness of pentoxifylline (Trental) in the treatment of intermittent claudication and ischemic rest pain, 129 patients were retrospectively interviewed with respect to compliance and improvement of symptoms. Risk factors for the development of atherosclerosis were tabulated, as was the severity of symptomatic lower extremity peripheral vascular insufficiency. The duration of pentoxifylline treatment was 35.8 +/- 45.0 weeks (mean +/- 1 S.D.). Forty-eight percent of the patients discontinued pentoxifylline on their own, most commonly because of side effects (13%) or perceived lack of improvement (23%). Of those patients taking pentoxifylline for eight weeks or more (n = 110), 64% noted some improvement, with 31% reporting increased claudication distance and 52% reduced claudication pain. Pentoxifylline provided pain relief in 52% of patients with ischemic rest pain (n = 27). Neither diabetes, hypertension, concomitant antiplatelet therapy, the severity of claudication, nor pretreatment ankle-brachial Doppler pressures were related to treatment outcome. Increased daily walking exercise during treatment was associated with successful outcome (p = 0.04). Clinical response to pentoxifylline was inversely related to the number of cigarettes smoked daily in those with 1 block claudication (n = 71, p = 0.05). Pentoxifylline was not very effective in increasing reported claudication distance. This review suggests that pentoxifylline may be of value for patients with ischemic rest pain when arterial reconstruction is not possible. Whether pentoxifylline is useful adjunctive therapy for intermittent claudication requires further scrutiny.
为评估己酮可可碱(曲克芦丁)治疗间歇性跛行和缺血性静息痛的临床疗效,我们对129例患者进行了回顾性访谈,了解其依从性和症状改善情况。列出了动脉粥样硬化发生的危险因素以及有症状的下肢周围血管功能不全的严重程度。己酮可可碱治疗的持续时间为35.8±45.0周(平均值±1个标准差)。48%的患者自行停用己酮可可碱,最常见的原因是副作用(13%)或感觉没有改善(23%)。在服用己酮可可碱8周或更长时间的患者(n = 110)中,64%的患者表示有一定改善,31%的患者报告跛行距离增加,52%的患者报告跛行疼痛减轻。己酮可可碱使52%的缺血性静息痛患者(n = 27)疼痛缓解。糖尿病、高血压、同时进行的抗血小板治疗、跛行的严重程度以及治疗前的踝肱多普勒压力均与治疗结果无关。治疗期间每日步行锻炼增加与治疗成功相关(p = 0.04)。在有1级跛行的患者中(n = 71,p = 0.05),己酮可可碱的临床反应与每日吸烟量呈负相关。己酮可可碱在增加报告的跛行距离方面效果不太明显。本综述表明,当无法进行动脉重建时,己酮可可碱可能对缺血性静息痛患者有价值。己酮可可碱是否是间歇性跛行的有用辅助治疗方法需要进一步研究。