Nakayama Don K, Thompson William M, Wynne Julie L, Dalton Martin L, Bozeman Andrew T, Innes Bruce J
Department of Surgery, Mercer University School of Medicine, Medical Center of Central Georgia, Macon, Georgia 31201, USA.
Am Surg. 2009 Dec;75(12):1234-7.
Resident work restrictions limit participation in operations that address problems created by a prior operation, because complications occur at any time. We compared resident and attending surgeon staffing of operative complications. We reviewed all complications that required a second operation reported at our Morbidity and Mortality Conference over 1 year, noting surgeons present, their postgraduate year level, and call shift. Comparisons were done using chi2. Of 142 cases, 39 involved a second operation. The same attending surgeon was present for both in 79 per cent of cases, whereas the same resident was present in only 44 per cent (P = 0.002). Postgraduate year 4 to 5 were less likely to be present for second operations than attendings (48% vs 87%, P = 0.011). Resident shift (day, night float, and weekend) was known in 32 cases. When the first operation occurred during day hours, attendings and residents were equally likely to be present at the second (55% and 45%, P = 0.16). When original operations took place during night float or weekend shifts, residents were less likely to be present (33%) than attendings (83%) at second operations (P = 0.036). Duty hour restrictions interfere with operative continuity of care. Reoperations should be exempted from duty hour restrictions.
住院医师工作限制限制了他们参与处理先前手术所产生问题的手术,因为并发症可能在任何时候发生。我们比较了住院医师和主治医生在手术并发症方面的人员配备情况。我们回顾了在我们的发病率和死亡率会议上报告的所有需要二次手术的并发症,记录在场的外科医生、他们的研究生年级以及值班班次。使用卡方检验进行比较。在142例病例中,39例涉及二次手术。79%的病例中两次手术的主治医生相同,而两次手术由同一名住院医师参与的情况仅占44%(P = 0.002)。与主治医生相比,四年级至五年级的研究生参与二次手术的可能性较小(48%对87%,P = 0.011)。在32例病例中了解住院医师的值班班次(白天、夜间轮值和周末)。当首次手术在白天进行时,主治医生和住院医师参与二次手术的可能性相同(分别为55%和45%,P = 0.16)。当首次手术在夜间轮值或周末班次进行时,住院医师参与二次手术的可能性低于主治医生(分别为33%和83%)(P = 0.036)。值班时间限制干扰了手术护理的连续性。再次手术应不受值班时间限制。