Department of Chemistry, Indian Institute of Technology Bombay Powai, Mumbai 400076.
J Org Chem. 2010 Jan 15;75(2):359-67. doi: 10.1021/jo902123x.
The mechanism of TiCl(4)-promoted Baylis-Hillman reaction between methyl vinyl ketone (MVK) and acetaldehyde, in the absence of any base, is studied using the mPW1K density functional theory. The study focuses on several mechanistic intricacies as well as selectivity issues at each step of the reaction. The minimum energy pathway for this reaction involves three major steps such as a chloride transfer resulting in a chloro-enolate, titanium-mediated aldol reaction, and elimination of HCl or HOTiCl(3). Both s-cis and s-trans conformers of MVK are considered along with various modes of chloride transfer involving different complexes between TiCl(4), aldehyde, and MVK. Chloride transfer is found to be kinetically more favored for s-cis-MVK than for s-trans-MVK. The diastereoselectivity in the next step, i.e., Ti-mediated aldol reaction between the enolate and aldehyde, is found to be dependent on the geometry of the enolate, wherein anti and syn BH products are predicted for Z and E enolates, respectively. An interesting secondary orbital interaction between the oxygen atoms of the enolate and aldehyde moieties in the transition states for the C-C bond formation is identified as one of the contributing factors toward the predicted diastereoselectivity in the formation of the alpha-chloromethyl aldol product (P2). It has earlier been reported that under different experimental conditions, any of the three products such as (i) a normal BH product (P1), (ii) 2-(chloromethyl)vinyl ketones (P3), and (iii) alpha-chloro methyl aldol could be generated (Scheme 1 ). The present study offers valuable insights toward rationalizing the observed product distribution as well as diastereoselectivity in TiCl(4)-promoted BH reaction under base-free conditions. The computed energetics indicate that when MVK is employed as the Michael acceptor, the formation of 2-(choromethyl)vinyl ketone is the preferred product rather than the corresponding normal BH product, consistent with the known experimental reports.
在没有任何碱的存在下,使用 mPW1K 密度泛函理论研究了 TiCl(4)促进的甲基乙烯基酮 (MVK) 和乙醛之间的 Baylis-Hillman 反应的机理。研究集中在反应的每一步中的几个机制复杂性以及选择性问题。该反应的最低能量途径涉及三个主要步骤,例如导致氯代烯醇盐的氯转移、钛介导的羟醛缩合反应以及 HCl 或 HOTiCl(3)的消除。考虑了 MVK 的 s-cis 和 s-trans 构象以及涉及 TiCl(4)、醛和 MVK 之间不同配合物的各种氯转移模式。发现对于 s-cis-MVK,氯转移在动力学上比 s-trans-MVK 更有利。下一步的非对映选择性,即烯醇盐与醛之间的钛介导羟醛缩合反应,发现取决于烯醇盐的几何形状,其中 Z 和 E 烯醇盐分别预测得到反式和顺式 BH 产物。在 C-C 键形成的过渡态中,烯醇盐和醛部分的氧原子之间存在有趣的二次轨道相互作用,这是预测形成α-氯甲基羟醛产物 (P2)的非对映选择性的因素之一。先前已经报道,在不同的实验条件下,可能会生成三种产物中的任何一种,即(i)正常的 BH 产物 (P1),(ii)2-(氯甲基)乙烯基酮 (P3)和 (iii)α-氯甲基羟醛 (Scheme 1)。本研究为在无碱条件下合理解释观察到的产物分布以及 TiCl(4)促进的 BH 反应的非对映选择性提供了有价值的见解。计算的能量学表明,当 MVK 用作迈克尔受体时,形成 2-(氯甲基)乙烯基酮是优选产物,而不是相应的正常 BH 产物,这与已知的实验报道一致。