Reed W, Poulos A, Rickard M, Brennan P
Discipline of Medical Radiation Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, The University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
J Med Imaging Radiat Oncol. 2009 Dec;53(6):530-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1754-9485.2009.02119.x.
Reader variability is a problem in mammography image reporting and compromises the efficacy of screening programmes. The purpose of this exploratory study was to survey reader practice in reporting screening mammograms in Australia to identify aspects of practice that warrant further investigation. Mammography reporting practice and influences on concentration and attention were investigated by using an original questionnaire distributed to screen readers in Australia. A response rate of 71% (83 out of 117) was achieved. Demographic data indicated that the majority of readers were over 46 years of age (73%), have been reporting on screening mammograms for over 10 years (61%), take less than 1 min to report upon a screening mammogram examination (66%), report up to 200 examinations in a single session (83%) and take up to 2 h to report one session (61%). A majority report on more than 5000 examinations annually (66%); 93% of participants regard their search strategy as systematic, 87% agreed that their concentration can vary throughout a session, 64% agreed that the relatively low number of positives can lead to lapses in concentration and attention and almost all (94%) participants agreed that methods to maximise concentration should be explored. Participants identified a range of influences on concentration within their working environment including volume of images reported in one session, image types and aspects of the physical environment. This study has provided important evidence of the need to investigate adverse influences on concentration during mammography screen reporting.
在乳腺钼靶图像报告中,阅片者之间的差异是一个问题,它会影响筛查项目的效果。这项探索性研究的目的是调查澳大利亚乳腺钼靶筛查报告中的阅片实践,以确定值得进一步研究的实践方面。通过向澳大利亚的乳腺钼靶阅片者发放一份原创问卷,对乳腺钼靶报告实践以及对注意力集中的影响进行了调查。获得了71%(117人中的83人)的回复率。人口统计学数据表明,大多数阅片者年龄超过46岁(73%),从事乳腺钼靶筛查报告工作超过10年(61%),报告一次乳腺钼靶筛查检查用时不到1分钟(66%),在一次工作时段内报告最多200例检查(83%),报告一次工作时段用时最多2小时(61%)。大多数人每年报告超过5000例检查(66%);93%的参与者认为他们的搜索策略是系统的,87%的人同意他们的注意力在整个工作时段可能会有所变化,64%的人同意阳性病例相对较少会导致注意力不集中,几乎所有(94%)参与者都同意应该探索提高注意力的方法。参与者指出了工作环境中一系列影响注意力的因素,包括一次工作时段内报告的图像数量、图像类型和物理环境方面。这项研究提供了重要证据,表明有必要调查乳腺钼靶筛查报告过程中对注意力的不利影响。