Baguelin-Pinaud A, Seguy C, Thibaut F
Inserm U614, UFR de médecine, service universitaire de psychiatrie, centre hospitalier du Rouvray, CHU Charles-Nicolle, 1, rue de Germont, 76031 Rouen cedex, France.
Encephale. 2009 Dec;35(6):538-43. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2008.08.005.
Deliberate self-injury is defined as the intentional, direct injuring of body tissue without suicidal intent. There are different types of deliberate self-mutilating behaviour: self cutting, phlebotomy, bites, burns, or ulcerations. Sometimes, especially among psychotic inpatients, eye, tongue, ear or genital self-mutilations have been reported. In fact, self-mutilation behaviour raises nosological and psychopathological questions. A consensus on a precise definition is still pending. Many authors consider self-mutilating behaviour as a distinct clinical syndrome, whereas others hold it to be a specific symptom of borderline personality disorder. Self-mutilating behaviour has been observed in 10 to 15% of healthy children, especially between the age of 9 and 18 months. These self mutilations are considered as pathological after the age of 3. Such behaviour is common among adolescents, with a higher proportion of females, and among psychiatric inpatients. Patients use different locations and methods for self-mutilation. Deliberate self harm syndrome is often associated with addictive behaviour, suicide attempt, and personality disorder.
We report on an observational study including 30 inpatients and we compared the data with the existing literature. As a matter of fact, until now, most of the papers deal with case reports or with very specific patterns of self-mutilation (eye, tongue or genital self-mutilations). Otherwise, papers report the relationships between self-mutilation and somatic or personality disorders (Lesh Nyhan syndrome, borderline personality disorder, dermatitis artefacta, self-mutilation in children following brachial plexus related to birth injury, mental retardation...). Our study included all self harmed patients who had been admitted to our psychiatric hospital (whatever the location and type of self-mutilation). Patients suffering from brain injury or mental retardation were excluded.
In our sample, there was a higher percentage of women (29 women and 1 man) and the mean age was 18 (12 to 37). More than half of the patients were aged under 18. Single parent families were reported in 30% of cases. Thirty percent of patients had been physically or sexually abused during childhood. Sixty percent had a comorbid psychiatric disorder, 63% had been hospitalised previously (half of them twice or more). Seventy-three percent of patients had previously attempted suicide (notably deliberate self-poisoning and cutting) that was not considered as self-mutilating behaviour by the patients themselves. Each patient had self harmed themselves at least twice and most often different methods and locations were used (deliberate self harm of forearms 90%, thighs 26.7%, legs 16.7%, chest 10%, belly 10%, hands 6.9%, face 6.9%, arms 6.7%, and feet 3.3%). Addictive disorders, such as substance abuse (tobacco 46.7%; alcohol 23.3%; illicit drugs 16.7% mostly cannabis or cocaine) and eating disorders (33.3% and among them 50% of cases were restrictive anorexia nervosa) were often associated with a deliberate self harm syndrome. Three psychiatric diagnoses were often observed in our cohort: depressive disorder 36.7%; personality disorder 20%; psychosis 10% and depressive disorder associated with personality disorder 33.3%. In our sample, psychotic patients differed on several clinical aspects: the atypical location (abdomen, nails) and method (needles) of self-mutilating behaviour. None of them had been abused during childhood and none was suffering from addictive disorders.
蓄意自伤被定义为故意直接伤害身体组织且无自杀意图。存在不同类型的蓄意自残行为:割伤自己、放血、咬伤、烧伤或溃疡。有时,尤其是在精神病住院患者中,会有眼部、舌头、耳朵或生殖器自残的报告。事实上,自残行为引发了疾病分类学和精神病理学方面的问题。关于精确的定义仍未达成共识。许多作者将自残行为视为一种独特的临床综合征,而另一些人则认为它是边缘性人格障碍的一种特定症状。在10%至15%的健康儿童中观察到了自残行为,尤其是在9至18个月大的时候。3岁以后,这些自残行为被视为病理性的。这种行为在青少年中很常见,女性比例更高,在精神病住院患者中也较为常见。患者使用不同的部位和方法进行自残。蓄意自伤综合征常与成瘾行为、自杀未遂和人格障碍相关。
我们报告一项观察性研究,纳入了30名住院患者,并将数据与现有文献进行了比较。事实上,到目前为止,大多数论文都涉及病例报告或非常特殊的自残模式(眼部、舌头或生殖器自残)。否则,论文报告的是自残与躯体或人格障碍之间的关系(莱施-尼汉综合征、边缘性人格障碍、人工皮炎、臂丛神经相关出生损伤后儿童的自残、智力迟钝……)。我们的研究纳入了所有入住我们精神病医院的自伤患者(无论自残的部位和类型)。患有脑损伤或智力迟钝的患者被排除。
在我们的样本中,女性比例更高(29名女性和1名男性),平均年龄为18岁(12至37岁)。超过一半的患者年龄在18岁以下。30%的病例报告为单亲家庭。30%的患者在童年时期遭受过身体或性虐待。60%的患者患有共病精神障碍,63%的患者曾住院治疗(其中一半患者住院两次或更多次)。73%的患者此前曾尝试自杀(主要是蓄意中毒和割伤),但患者自己并不认为这是自残行为。每位患者至少自残过两次,且大多使用不同的方法和部位(前臂蓄意自伤90%、大腿26.7%、腿部16.7%、胸部10%、腹部10%、手部6.9%、面部6.9%、手臂6.7%、脚部3.3%)。成瘾性障碍,如物质滥用(烟草46.7%;酒精23.3%;非法药物16.7%,主要是大麻或可卡因)和饮食失调(33.3%,其中50%的病例为限制性神经性厌食症)常与蓄意自伤综合征相关。在我们的队列中经常观察到三种精神诊断:抑郁症36.7%;人格障碍20%;精神病10%;抑郁症合并人格障碍33.3%。在我们的样本中,精神病患者在几个临床方面有所不同:自残行为的非典型部位(腹部、指甲)和方法(针刺)。他们中没有人在童年时期遭受过虐待,也没有人患有成瘾性障碍。