National Department of Neurosurgery, Beaumont Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2009 Dec 15;34(26):2880-5. doi: 10.1097/BRS.0b013e3181b4e218.
STUDY DESIGN.: Observational study. Retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data. OBJECTIVE.: The purpose of this article was to report long-term (minimum 7 years) clinical and radiologic outcome of our series of patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis who underwent transarticular screw fixation to treat atlantoaxial subluxation. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.: The indications for intervention in patients with atlantoaxial instability are pain, myelopathy, and progressive neurologic deficit. The various treatment options available for these patients are isolated C1-C2 fusion, occipitocervical fusion with or without transoral surgery. Review of current literature suggests that C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation has significant functional benefits, although there is discrepancy in this literature regarding improvement in function following surgery. METHODS.: Myelopathy was assessed using Ranawat myelopathy score and Myelopathy Disability Index. Pain scores were assessed using Visual Analogue Scale. The radiologic imaging was assessed and the following data were extracted; atlanto-dens interval, space available for cord, presence of signal change on T2 weighted image, and fusion rates. RESULTS.: Thirty-seven patients, median age 56, were included in the study. Average duration of neck symptoms was 15.8 months. Average duration of rheumatoid arthritis before surgery was 20.6 years. Preoperative symptoms: suboccipital pain in 26 patients; neck pain, 32; myelopathy, 22; and 5 were asymptomatic. After surgery: suboccipital pain, 2; neck pain, 3; and myelopathy, 10. Ninety percent patients with neck and suboccipital pain improved after surgery in their Visual Analogue pain scores, with all of them having >50% improvement in VAS scores (6.94-2.12 [P < 0.05]).Preoperative Ranawat grade was as follows: grade 1 in 15 patients, grade 2 in 7, and grade 3a in 14, grade 3b in 1.After surgery: grade 1 in 27 patients, grade 2 in 7, grade 3a in 1, and grade 3b in 2. The mean myelopathy score improved after surgery (59.62-32.75, P < 0.05).The space available for the cord was improved in 63%, unchanged in 33%, and worse in 4%.Twenty-seven percent had T2 signal change and 18% had cervicomedullary compression; 97% had bony fusion. BILATERAL SCREWS WERE USED IN 33 PATIENTS AND UNILATERAL SCREWS IN 4 PATIENTS (ABERRANT VERTEBRAL ARTERY).: Computer image guidance was used in 73%. CONCLUSION.: C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation is a safe technique for atlantoaxial subluxation for patients with rheumatoid arthritis. This study clearly demonstrates improvement in Visual Analogue Scale, Ranawat grading and the Myelopathy Disability Index even at long-term follow up.
观察性研究。对前瞻性收集的数据进行回顾性分析。目的:本文旨在报告我们一系列类风湿关节炎患者接受经关节螺钉固定治疗寰枢关节半脱位的长期(至少 7 年)临床和影像学结果。背景资料摘要:寰枢关节不稳定患者的干预指征为疼痛、脊髓病和进行性神经功能缺损。这些患者的各种治疗选择包括单纯 C1-C2 融合、寰枕融合伴或不伴经口手术。对当前文献的回顾表明,C1-C2 经关节螺钉固定具有显著的功能益处,尽管文献中关于手术后功能改善存在差异。方法:使用 Ranawat 脊髓病评分和脊髓病残疾指数评估脊髓病。使用视觉模拟评分法评估疼痛评分。评估影像学,并提取以下数据:寰齿间距、脊髓可用空间、T2 加权图像上的信号改变和融合率。结果:37 例患者,中位年龄 56 岁,纳入研究。颈部症状平均持续时间为 15.8 个月。术前类风湿关节炎平均持续时间为 20.6 年。术前症状:枕下疼痛 26 例;颈部疼痛 32 例;脊髓病 22 例;无症状 5 例。手术后:枕下疼痛 2 例;颈部疼痛 3 例;脊髓病 10 例。90%的颈部和枕下疼痛患者术后视觉模拟疼痛评分改善,所有患者 VAS 评分改善>50%(6.94-2.12,P<0.05)。术前 Ranawat 分级如下:15 例为 1 级,7 例为 2 级,14 例为 3a 级,1 例为 3b 级。术后:27 例为 1 级,7 例为 2 级,1 例为 3a 级,2 例为 3b 级。术后脊髓病评分改善(59.62-32.75,P<0.05)。脊髓可用空间改善 63%,无变化 33%,恶化 4%。27%的患者 T2 信号改变,18%的患者颈髓受压;97%的患者有骨融合。33 例患者使用双侧螺钉,4 例患者使用单侧螺钉(椎动脉异常)。73%的患者使用计算机图像引导。结论:C1-C2 经关节螺钉固定是治疗类风湿关节炎寰枢关节半脱位的一种安全技术。本研究清楚地表明,即使在长期随访中,视觉模拟量表、Ranawat 分级和脊髓病残疾指数也有改善。