Suppr超能文献

19世纪法国的社会学与实证主义:社会学协会的兴衰(1872 - 1874)

Sociology and positivism in 19th-century France: the vicissitudes of the Société de sociologie (1872-4).

作者信息

Heilbron Johan

机构信息

Centre de Sociologie Européenne (Univ. of Paris-Sorbonne), Paris, France

出版信息

Hist Human Sci. 2009 Oct;22(4):30-62. doi: 10.1177/0952695109337691.

Abstract

Little is known about the world's first sociological society, Emile Littré's Société de Sociologie (1872-4). This article, based on prosopographic research, offers an interpretation of the foundation, political-intellectual orientation and early demise of the society. As indicated by recruitment and texts by its founding members, the Société de Sociologie was in fact conceived more as a political club than a learned society. Guided in this by Littré's heterodox positivism and the redefinition of sociology he proposed around 1870, the Société de Sociologie was intended first and foremost to accompany intellectually the political changes that Littré considered imperative in the early years of the Third Republic (1870-1940). This expectation found little echo among the members of the society, and it seems possible that Littré himself and his closest associates were the ones to interrupt the society's meetings. Some of its members' general studies on the status of the social sciences and their main divisions were continued in the framework of the journal "La Philosophie positive" (1867-83), but the authors most committed to those studies were on the margins of the Littré network. Neither the dominant positivist republicanism, centered around Littré and Dubost, nor the general sociology of the more peripheral members of the network (Mesmer, Roberty, Vitry) represented an important intellectual contribution to the formation of academic sociology in France. Given that the Société de Sociologie did contribute to diffuse the project of a sociological science and developed forms of sociology coherent enough to be rejected by the pioneers of university sociology, the group constitutes a significant case of failure in the history of the discipline.

摘要

关于世界上第一个社会学协会——埃米尔·利特雷的社会学协会(1872 - 1874年),人们所知甚少。本文基于人物志研究,对该协会的成立、政治 - 知识导向及早期消亡作出了解读。从其创始成员的招募情况和著作来看,社会学协会实际上更多地被构想为一个政治俱乐部,而非学术团体。在利特雷的异端实证主义以及他在1870年左右对社会学所提出的重新定义的引导下,社会学协会首要目的是在知识层面上伴随利特雷认为在第三共和国早期(1870 - 1940年)势在必行的政治变革。这种期望在协会成员中几乎没有得到回应,而且似乎是利特雷本人及其最亲密的伙伴中断了协会的会议。其一些成员对社会科学的地位及其主要分支的一般性研究在《实证哲学》杂志(1867 - 1883年)的框架内得以延续,但最致力于这些研究的作者处于利特雷圈子的边缘。无论是以利特雷和迪博斯特为中心的占主导地位的实证主义共和主义,还是该圈子中较为边缘的成员(梅斯梅尔、罗贝蒂、维特里)的一般社会学,都没有对法国学术社会学的形成作出重要的知识贡献。鉴于社会学协会确实为传播社会学科学的项目作出了贡献,并且发展出了足够连贯的社会学形式,以至于遭到了大学社会学先驱们的否定,该团体在学科史上构成了一个显著的失败案例。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验