Center for Biological Safety and Research, National Institute of Health Sciences, Tokyo 158-8501, Japan.
Chem Biol Interact. 2010 Mar 19;184(1-2):240-5. doi: 10.1016/j.cbi.2009.12.005. Epub 2009 Dec 16.
In this study, Trp53-deficient and wild-type mice of both C57BL/6 and C3H/He strains were exposed to benzene (33, 100, and 300 ppm; 6h/day, 5 days/week for 26 weeks) and then observed for lifetime. As results, first, the incidence of nonthymic lymphomas in C57BL/6 mice and acute myeloid leukemias (AMLs) in C3H/He mice showed linear responses at the lower exposure level in Trp53-deficient mice; second, the incidence of thymic lymphomas in C57BL/6 mice and nonthymic lymphomas in C3H/He mice increased without a plateau-like ceiling; thus, the former equivocal induction of hematopoietic neoplasms (HPNs) in the case of low-dose benzene exposure was assumed to be based on the DNA repair potential in wild-type mice, and the latter limited increase in HPNs in the case of high-dose benzene exposure was considered to be due to excessive apoptosis in wild-type mice. Concerning the incidence of AMLs, though a dose of 300 ppm benzene inhalation induced 9% AMLs in wild-type C3H/He mice-AML-prone, it induced AMLs in 38% of Trp53-deficient C3H/He mice. Because AMLs were also observed in Trp53-deficient mice, including in the C57BL/6 mice, benzene exposure may also be a potent inducer of AMLs in mice with some strain differences. In the present study, to elucidate the hematopoietic stem cell-specific, aryl hydrocarbon-receptor-related low-dose adverse effect, global gene expression in the bone marrow was analyzed at 28 days after 2-week-intermittent exposure to 150 mg/kg b.w. benzene, by gavage, i.e., equivalent to the above inhalation protocol with 300 ppm. We observed two conceptually different gene expression profiles; "common gene profiles" (CGPs) shared among mice in each group, and "stochastic gene profiles" (SGPs), i.e., unique union genes from one individual mouse to another. The CGPs of the experimental group and the SGPs of each individual mouse were separately characterized by individual assay. Concerning the CGPs, reciprocal strain differences between C3H/He and C57BL/6 mice in expression gene profiles, both plausible for leukemogenesis, were identified; namely, dominant downmodulations of Sltm and Cryl1, related to suppression of apoptosis and genomic instability in C3H/He mice, respectively, and dominant downmodulations of Atrx/rad54 and Kdm2a, related to a decrease in DNA repair and genomic instability, respectively, in C57BL/6 mice. These findings imply that these reciprocal gene expression differences induced by benzene exposure may lead each strain to undergo different hematopoietic neoplastic pathways. In contrast, each individual mouse often shows a unique SGP. SGPs often include transcription factors, which regulate reciprocal signaling pathways including further SGPs. Among them, apoptosis-related genes expressed in C57BL/6 mice and those in C3H/He mice were attributable to different combinations of SGPs. Such stochastic case-by-case gene expression may be in good agreement with the individual and strain differences observed following benzene exposure. Because gene chip microarray techniques can elucidate stochastic changes in gene expression profiles, possible stochastic toxicology and its future role are discussed.
在这项研究中,C57BL/6 和 C3H/He 品系的 Trp53 缺陷型和野生型小鼠分别暴露于苯(33、100 和 300ppm;每天 6 小时,每周 5 天,共 26 周),然后进行终生观察。结果表明,首先,C57BL/6 小鼠中非胸腺性淋巴瘤和 C3H/He 小鼠急性髓性白血病(AML)的发生率在 Trp53 缺陷型小鼠的低暴露水平呈线性反应;其次,C57BL/6 小鼠的胸腺性淋巴瘤和 C3H/He 小鼠的非胸腺性淋巴瘤的发生率呈上升趋势,没有平台状上限;因此,前者在低剂量苯暴露情况下造血肿瘤(HPN)的可疑诱导被认为是基于野生型小鼠的 DNA 修复潜力,后者在高剂量苯暴露情况下 HPN 的有限增加被认为是由于野生型小鼠的过度细胞凋亡。关于 AML 的发生率,尽管 300ppm 苯吸入诱导 9%的野生型 C3H/He 小鼠(AML 易感)发生 AML,但它在 38%的 Trp53 缺陷型 C3H/He 小鼠中诱导 AML。因为 AML 也在 Trp53 缺陷型小鼠中观察到,包括 C57BL/6 小鼠中,苯暴露也可能是具有某些品系差异的 AML 的潜在诱导剂。在本研究中,为了阐明造血干细胞特异性、芳香烃受体相关的低剂量不良效应,通过灌胃给予相当于上述 300ppm 吸入方案的 150mg/kg b.w.苯,在 2 周间歇性暴露后 28 天分析骨髓中的全基因组表达。我们观察到两种概念上不同的基因表达谱;每组小鼠共享的“共同基因谱(CGP)”和每个个体小鼠特有的“随机基因谱(SGP)”。实验组的 CGP 和每个个体小鼠的 SGP 分别通过个体分析进行了特征描述。关于 CGP,在 C3H/He 和 C57BL/6 小鼠之间鉴定了与白血病发生相关的表达基因谱的相互反向的品系差异;即,Sltm 和 Cryl1 的表达下调,分别与 C3H/He 小鼠的细胞凋亡抑制和基因组不稳定性相关,Atrx/rad54 和 Kdm2a 的表达下调,分别与 C57BL/6 小鼠的 DNA 修复减少和基因组不稳定性相关。这些发现表明,苯暴露引起的这些相互反向的基因表达差异可能导致每个品系经历不同的造血肿瘤途径。相反,每个个体小鼠通常表现出独特的 SGP。SGP 通常包括转录因子,它们调节包括进一步 SGP 的相互信号通路。其中,C57BL/6 小鼠中表达的凋亡相关基因和 C3H/He 小鼠中表达的基因归因于不同组合的 SGP。这种随机的逐案基因表达可能与苯暴露后观察到的个体和品系差异非常吻合。由于基因芯片微阵列技术可以阐明基因表达谱的随机变化,因此讨论了可能的随机毒理学及其未来作用。