Mullis Ronald L, Graf Shruti Chatterjee, Mullis Ann K
Florida State University, Department of Family and Child Sciences, Tallahassee, FL 32306, USA.
J Genet Psychol. 2009 Dec;170(4):326-38. doi: 10.1080/00221320903218356.
To examine the interrelations among parental relationships, emotional autonomy, and identity statuses, the authors asked 234 (105 male, 129 female) high school students to complete the Parental Bonding Scale (G. Parker, H. Tupling, & L. B. Brown, 1979), Emotional Autonomy Scale (L. D. Steinberg & S. B. Silverberg, 1986), and Extended Objective Measure of Ego Identity Scale-II (L. D. Bennion & G. R. Adams, 1986). There continues to be controversy about whether adolescents' identity formation is related to their emotional separation from their parents. According to Eriksonian and neo-Eriksonian theory (J. E. Marcia, 1980, 1984), adolescents who are successful in resolving their identity issues are better able to emotionally individuate from their parents. That is, adolescents have fewer conflicts with parents as they become more independent of them. Results of the present study indicate that adolescent perceptions of mother's caring behavior, but not father's caring behavior, predicted higher foreclosure identity status scores among adolescents. In addition, 2 dimensions of emotional autonomy (i.e., perceiving parents as people and parental deidealization) best predicted the adolescent identity statuses of moratorium and foreclosure. Results also indicate that future research may need to establish a better theoretical conceptualization of the constructs of interest in this study and better measures of emotional autonomy among adolescents.
为了探究亲子关系、情感自主性和身份状态之间的相互关系,作者让234名(105名男性,129名女性)高中生完成父母教养方式量表(G. 帕克、H. 图普林和L. B. 布朗,1979年)、情感自主量表(L. D. 斯坦伯格和S. B. 西尔弗伯格,1986年)以及自我身份扩展客观测量量表-II(L. D. 本尼恩和G. R. 亚当斯,1986年)。关于青少年的身份形成是否与其与父母的情感分离有关,一直存在争议。根据埃里克森和新埃里克森理论(J. E. 马西亚,1980年、1984年),成功解决身份问题的青少年在情感上更能与父母分离。也就是说,随着青少年变得更加独立于父母,他们与父母的冲突会减少。本研究结果表明,青少年对母亲关爱行为的认知,而非对父亲关爱行为的认知,预测了青少年中更高的封闭型身份状态得分。此外,情感自主性的两个维度(即将父母视为普通人以及对父母的去理想化)最能预测青少年的延缓型和封闭型身份状态。结果还表明,未来的研究可能需要对本研究中感兴趣的构念建立更好的理论概念化,并对青少年的情感自主性进行更好的测量。