Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development (CSDD), Boston, Massachusetts 02111, USA.
MAbs. 2009 Jan-Feb;1(1):56-66. doi: 10.4161/mabs.1.1.7246.
Precision binding of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to biological targets, their relative clinical success, and expansion of indications following initial approval, are distinctive clinical features. The relatively high cost of mAbs, together with the absence of a regulatory pathway to generics, stand out as distinctive economic features. Based on both literature review and primary data collection we enumerated mAb original approvals, supplemental indications and off-label uses, assessed payer formulary management of mAbs, and determined new challenges to Medicare beneficiary access to mAbs. We found that the FDA has approved 22 mAbs and 30 supplemental indications pertaining to the originally approved mAbs. In addition, there are 46 off-label use citations in officially recognized pharmaceutical compendia. Across Part B carriers and Part D plans, we found considerable variation in terms of coverage and conditions of reimbursement related to on- and off-label uses of mAbs. Our results point to four major challenges facing mAb developers, health care providers, Medicare beneficiaries, payers and policymakers. These include administrative price controls, coverage variation, projected shift from physician- to self-administered mAbs, and comparative effectiveness. We suggest more systematic use of "coverage with evidence development" as a means of optimally addressing these challenges.
单克隆抗体 (mAbs) 与生物靶标的精确结合、相对临床成功以及初始批准后的适应症扩展是其独特的临床特征。mAbs 相对较高的成本,加上缺乏仿制药监管途径,是其独特的经济特征。基于文献回顾和原始数据收集,我们列举了 mAb 的原始批准、补充适应症和标签外使用情况,评估了 mAb 的支付者处方管理,并确定了医疗保险受益人的 mAb 获得新挑战。我们发现,FDA 已批准了 22 种 mAb 和 30 种与最初批准的 mAb 相关的补充适应症。此外,在官方认可的药物学手册中还有 46 个标签外使用引文。在 Part B 承运人和 Part D 计划中,我们发现与 mAb 的标签内和标签外使用相关的覆盖范围和报销条件存在相当大的差异。我们的结果指出了 mAb 开发商、医疗保健提供者、医疗保险受益人、支付者和政策制定者面临的四个主要挑战。这些挑战包括行政价格控制、覆盖范围的变化、预计从医生管理到自我管理 mAb 的转变以及疗效比较。我们建议更系统地使用“有证据开发的覆盖范围”作为解决这些挑战的最佳手段。