Pineault R, Maheux B, Lambert J, Béland F, Lévesque A
Department of Social and Preventive Medicine, University of Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Int J Health Serv. 1991;21(1):49-58. doi: 10.2190/YRCQ-53CW-165X-T803.
Since the early 1970s, there have been two primary care networks in Quebec: the traditional one characterized by private practice remunerated on a fee-for-service basis, and the public one comprising 15 percent of physicians and characterized by salaried practice within publicly funded local community health service centers (CLSCs). Using data collected on 616 Quebec generalists, 333 in private practice and 283 in CLSCs, we compared physicians' profiles in both networks. In contrast to their colleagues in private practice, CLSC physicians are younger, more often women, and more often graduates of innovative primary care training programs. They are more sensitive to the biopsychosocial nature of health problems and to giving patients an active role in their care. Significant differences were also observed in physicians' self-reported clinical practices, more so for women than for men. The study suggests that alternative primary care settings attract physicians that are more preventive and socially oriented. As a result, they may contribute to the emergence of a more comprehensive type of medical practice in health care delivery systems.
自20世纪70年代初以来,魁北克有两个初级保健网络:一个是传统网络,其特点是以按服务收费方式支付报酬的私人执业;另一个是公共网络,由15%的医生组成,其特点是在公共资助的当地社区卫生服务中心(CLSCs)内进行 salaried 执业。我们利用收集到的616名魁北克全科医生的数据,其中333名从事私人执业,283名在CLSCs工作,比较了两个网络中医生的概况。与私人执业的同行相比,CLSC的医生更年轻,女性比例更高,并且更多是创新初级保健培训项目的毕业生。他们对健康问题的生物心理社会性质以及让患者在其护理中发挥积极作用更为敏感。在医生自我报告的临床实践中也观察到了显著差异,女性比男性更为明显。该研究表明,替代性初级保健环境吸引了更具预防性和社会导向性的医生。因此,它们可能有助于在医疗保健提供系统中出现一种更全面的医疗实践类型。